History shows why the Cleveland Browns can go 12-4 this season: Doug Lesmerises 3rd & Short | cleveland.com
https://expo.cleveland.com/sports/g66l-2...3rd-short-.htmlSTANDING STRONG ON THE 12-4 BROWNS
We return after a two-week absence with a re-statement of principle that, in the year since 3rd & Short was birthed, defines us as much as anything written in this space.
The Browns are going 12-4 in 2019.
You know this. But a month before camp begins, we’re going to explain exactly how reasonable a prediction that is. Truly, the NFL is designed for a team just like the Browns to win 12 games immediately after a seven-win season.
This is the way of the league.
According to recent Las Vegas odds, the Browns are the favorite to win the AFC North, but the slightest favorite among the eight divisions. Philadelphia, Chicago, New Orleans, the L.A. Rams, New England, Indianapolis and Kansas City are all stronger picks to win their divisions.
Fine. At least the Browns are the division favorite, which their roster justifies.
At 7-1 odds, the Browns are tied with the Colts, behind the Chiefs and Patriots, as the third choice to win the AFC.
Fine. Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady justify that.
At 14-1, the Browns are the fifth choice to win the Super Bowl, behind New England, Kansas City, the Rams and the Saints.
That, actually, is a little crazy in my mind. The Patriots have 6-1 odds; the Chiefs, Rams and Saints are 10-1; and the Browns are only 14-1, with a first-year head coach and a roster populated by guys who have never done this. Even new additions Odell Beckham, Sheldon Richardson, Olivier Vernon and Kareem Hunt have never won a playoff game.
Any 12-win prediction banks on the idea that when it comes to health, leadership, game-calling and locker-room dynamics, almost everything will go right to supplement a roster filled with true talent. But even I’m not thinking all that is going to lead to three playoff wins (yes, at 12-4 a first-round bye is on the table) for a team that has three playoff wins in the last 32 years.
This isn’t about January, and whether the Browns can beat three or four of the best teams in the NFL. This is about four months of football in the fall, when the Browns should on a weekly basis take advantage of one of the 10 easiest schedules in the league.
Our 12-4 prediction arrived in December, before the 2018 season was over. Slowly, others have agreed … almost. When the full NFL schedule was released in April, ESPN predicted records for every team and checked in at 11-5 for the Browns. Louis Riddick did the same on the NFL Network and also reached 11-5.
Of course, that’s not quite 12-4.
Even Joe Thomas, who has positioned himself to be the grand old man of Browns football for the next four decades, went through the schedule on the NFL Network in May and, game-by-game, arrived at 10-6, but only after a four-game winning streak to end the season.
No reason to hedge, Joe. Here’s why: 12-4 seasons come out of nowhere all the time.
In the last 10 seasons, a team has won at least 12 games 46 times. That’s 4.6 a year. And it has been spread around. Here are the 12-win seasons in the last decade by franchise:
In the last 10 seasons, a team has won at least 12 games 46 times. That’s 4.6 a year. And it has been spread around. Here are the 12-win seasons in the last decade by franchise:
8 New England
4 Denver
3 Pittsburgh
3 New Orleans
2 Kansas City
2 Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers
2 Minnesota
2 Dallas
2 Carolina
2 Seattle
2 Green Bay
2 Atlanta
2 San Francisco
2 Baltimore
1 Houston
1 Arizona
1 Philadelphia
1 Chicago
1 Los Angeles Rams
1 Oakland
1 Cincinnati
1 Indianapolis
That’s 22 of the 32 teams, 69 percent of the league, with at least one 12-win season in the last decade. I think too many Browns fans, upon hearing a 12-win prediction, imagine that level of success as a fanciful paradise of competence reserved for Tom Brady, Bill Belichick, Peyton Manning and Mike Tomlin.
Not true. Almost any team can get itself together for a season where lousy opponents match up with actual skill, and, boom, 12 wins.
The rotation of divisions in the schedule means that the Browns lucked into the AFC East and NFC West in 2019. By finishing third in the AFC North last year, the Browns also get the third-place teams from the AFC South (Tennessee) and AFC West (Denver), which means two winnable games, while the AFC North champion Ravens get Houston and Kansas City, and second-place Pittsburgh gets Indianapolis and the L.A. Chargers.
The rules are helping the Browns get to 12-4 because they weren’t great last year as a 7-8-1, third-place team. So if you think making a jump from mediocre to 12-4 is exceedingly difficult, it’s actually staying on top once you’ve won your division that’s far more difficult.
What the Browns need to reach 12 wins is a five-win jump from the year before.
We’re actually going to talk about teams that made at least a four-win jump, because the Browns have that tie in 2018 that means they only need to be 4 ½ games better to reach 12 wins, and they also dumped Hue Jackson, which is worth like an extra half-win on its own that we can factor it.
But first, we must toss out the dynasties, because there’s a certain kind of 12-win team that has nothing to do with the 2019 Browns: the teams that do it all the time.
In the last 10 years, the teams that did not make a four-win jump on the way to 12 wins include the Patriots seven times, the Steelers three times and Peyton Manning teams in Indianapolis and Denver four times.
This is the same kind of stat as the one showing that 16 of the last 18 Super Bowl appearances by AFC teams have been taken by Brady (nine), Manning (four) and Roethlisberger (three).
We’re not comparing Baker Mayfield to those quarterbacks … yet. But if the QB and 3rd & Short are both around eight or 10 years from now, we could be doing that. So we’re not comparing the Browns to the teams of those QBs. There’s no point. It’s a different conversation.
So, that means of the 46 teams that won at least 12 games in the last 10 years, we’re removing 14 teams -- seven in New England, three in Pittsburgh, three in Denver and one in Indianapolis.
That leaves us with 32 12-win teams worth comparing to where the Browns are.
Of those teams, 16 made at least a four-win jump, and 16 did not. Basically, half the non-dynasty teams to reach 12 wins in the last decade were just like the Browns.
So this is what a 12-4 Browns season would be: reasonable, normal, and given how much the Browns have improved since the middle of last season, practically expected.
Your friends think you’re looped for saying the Browns are going 12-4? Tell them it’s even crazier to think the Browns can’t do it.
Here are the 16 teams in the last 10 year that made at least a four-game jump on the way to winning at least 12 games. And 12 of these 16 made the actual five-game leap that the Browns would require.
● 2009 San Diego Chargers, 13-3 after 8-8 in 2008
● 2009 New Orleans Saints, 13-3 after 8-8 in 2008
● 2010 New England Patriots, 14-2 after 10-6 in 2009
● 2010 Atlanta Falcons, 13-3 after 9-7 in 2009
● 2011 Green Bay Packers, 15-1 after 10-6 in 2010
● 2011 San Francisco 49ers, 13-3 after 6-10 in 2010
● 2012 Denver Broncos, 13-3 after 8-8 in 2011
● 2013 Carolina Panthers, 12-4 after 7-9 in 2012
● 2014 Dallas Cowboys, 12-4 after 8-8 in 2013
● 2014 Green Bay Packers, 12-4 after 8-8 in 2013
● 2015 Carolina Panthers, 15-1 after 7-9 in 2014
● 2016 Oakland Raiders, 12-4 after 7-9 in 2015
● 2016 Dallas Cowboys, 13-3 after 4-12 in 2015
● 2017 Philadelphia Eagles, 13-3 after 7-9 in 2016
● 2017 Minnesota Vikings, 13-3 after 8-8 in 2016
● 2018 Chicago Bears, 12-4 after 5-11 in 2017
In there are some very good teams that had down years and bounced back big (like 2014 Green Bay). There also are teams that steadily built to 12 wins that we haven’t specifically mentioned, the 16 teams outside of the QB stars that reached 12 wins without a four-game jump.
Cincinnati went from 10 wins in 2014 to 12 wins in 2015. The Chargers went from 9 wins in 2017 to 12 last year. The Chiefs went from 10 wins in 2017 to 12 last year. Incremental progress is admirable.
But the leaps to 12-4? They’re just as logical. That’s why when it happens with the Browns this season, you shouldn’t be surprised. Of all the teams that made the leap, here are the three that share the most in common with the 2019 Browns.
THREE TEAMS THAT MADE A JUMP TO 12 WINS THAT LOOK LIKE THE 2019 BROWNS
3. 2013 CAROLINA PANTHERS
The Panthers started a third-year quarterback, not a second-year quarterback, but this was a former No. 1 pick coming into his own, backed by a young defense. Cam Newton actually saw his raw numbers come down -- this wasn’t his MVP season or the Super Bowl run he would construct two years later. But the Panthers pulled together everything around him, as linebacker Luke Kuechly reached his first Pro Bowl and Carolina finished on an 11-1 run after a 1-3 start.
After just one winning season in the previous seven, and bottoming out at 2-14 in 2010 to get the chance to draft Newton, the new-look Panthers arrived.
They’ve had up-and-down moments since, but this was clearly the start of an era, something that was built and has been maintained with that QB and key defenders. The Panthers have made the playoffs four of the last six seasons, and overall are 58-37-1 in those six years.
It started by going 12-4 in 2013 after a record of 7-9 the previous season. The Panthers aren’t the Patriots, but they’ve shown some staying power that could certainly be replicated in Cleveland.
Four playoff appearances, including a Super Bowl, in six years? It would be hard for the Browns to argue with that.
2. 2016 OAKLAND RAIDERS
The previous losing looks very familiar here. If the Raiders could jump to 12 wins, the Browns absolutely can. The Raiders didn’t have a winning season for 13 years before stepping up from 7-9 in 2015 to 12-4 in 2016. Even the Browns are only at 11 seasons without a winning record right now.
Again, obviously, it started with the quarterback. From 3-13 in his first year as a starter, then to 7-9, Derek Carr led this revival in year three. But that wasn’t all. The Raiders featured Defensive Player of the Year Khalil Mack, who won the award in his third season (we’re talking to you, Myles Garrett).
The Raiders also added four key starters in free agency and saw ready-to-win players in their late 20s pay immediate dividends after smart signings. Again, does that remind you of anything?
The issue for the Raiders was that they couldn’t capitalize and couldn’t maintain it. Carr broke his leg in Week 16, and the Raiders were a shadow of themselves in their playoff loss. Then the whole thing went south. They followed 12-4 with 6-10, then fired their head coach and traded Mack.
The Browns don’t want to emulate a path that nets them Jon Gruden as a supposed savior. Oakland isn’t a model of sustaining it. But the Raiders are an ideal example of the leap to 12-4.
1. 2018 CHICAGO BEARS
We wrote a lot last year about how the Los Angeles Rams could be a model for the Browns, and we were right on. From 4-12 to 11-5 to 13-3 last year, they showed how firing the wrong coach, hiring the right coach, and building quickly by spending on veterans can flip a franchise.
But the Rams aren’t the only very recent example.
The Bears made a bigger leap last season, moving from 5-11 in 2017 to 12-4 in 2018 behind the kind of superstar acquisition that most resembles the Browns getting Beckham.
The Bears traded for Mack (boy, is he important to winning), featured a diversified rushing attack behind a second-year quarterback in Mitch Trubisky and immediately won for first-year coach Matt Nagy, a former offensive coordinator.
Freddie Kitchens is Nagy, Beckham is Mack, Baker Mayfield is Trubisky and anything the Bears did, the Browns absolutely can do as well. They were stacked with vital contributors in their mid-20s, just like the Browns. It wasn’t their Super Bowl year, but it was their year to show how much they had changed. And how much they could win.
There are more examples. Philadelphia’s Super Bowl year with second-year QB Carson Wentz followed a seven-win season. Dallas made a nine-win jump in 2016 after adding Dak Prescott and Ezekiel Elliott. It doesn’t guarantee it will happen for the Browns in 2019, though nothing short of a catastrophe will shake me off 12-4 until that fifth loss is in the books.
But clearly, you have to understand that the Browns going 12-4 this season isn’t crazy.