OK, I am finally home, and I will try to get through your questions.
That is great that you have a personal relationship with God. I am actually a little bit jealous of that because I have difficulty understanding what you mean by it. Do you talk to God? Does God talk to you? Has he revealed himself to you in some unmistakable way? Are you implying that the voice in your head/subconscious mind is actually God? When I was younger, I did indeed try to reach out to God and to be quite blunt, never got anywhere with that. There were no lines of communication. It is all faith and no evidence, which bothers me, because I am a 'show me' kind of guy. I even tried praying before and some of those prayers were indeed answered. However, it seemed as if the prayers were answered at about the same rate that they would have been had I never prayed in the first place.
I have told this story before, but my communication with God is not a spoken word, where I hear His voice audibly.
Rather, I feel His voice. I have told the story many times of how I was ready to kill myself because of bad reaction to a medication my doctor gave me. I was freaking out, sweating like crazy, and truly going insane, The medication really had a horrible effect on me. (it turns out that I am very allergic to this particular medication) Anyway, at the depths of my despair, and with anger raging within me, and just generally freaking out, I called out to God, yelling, swearing at Him ..... I was not very nice.
I then felt this presence. That is the only way to describe it. This incredible calm came over me, and I was back to normal in a heartbeat. I .. well, I can only describe it as feeling God telling me that everything was going to be OK, and that He wanted me to follow Him.
It was the single most powerful experience of my entire life.
It is like that when God answers one of my prayers. (It doesn't happen every time. Not every prayer requires God to speak to me, and not every answer has to be verbal, or an approximation)
I had problems, as I was in deep financial problems due to my medical situation, and not having any insurance for almost 2 years. I finally decided to turn my finances over to God. Miraculous things started happening. (and I can prove every one of these) My long term disability was going to cut off the month before my Social Security started, and without medical insurance, I was going to be in trouble. The woman with the insurance company said that she would check to see if there was anything they could do. I figured that was just lip service, but I just felt God say not to worry ..... so I didn't.
The woman from the insurance company called me back, and said that she did some checking into the master policy and she found that mine had a rider, that covered the transition period from insurance to Social Security. She said that she had never seen a policy with it ever before, but mine somehow had it, so she sent me a check fir 3 months of insurance.
My father turned up, after being missing from the lives of myself and my brothers. I felt God tell me to forgive him, but I resisted. I continued to feel this need to forgive him, and so I decided that I should, as we are to forgive if we are to be forgiven.
My dad has done well for himself, and he came up for a visit, and sent me and my brother each a rather sizable check. I had no thought of even seeing my father ever again.
There was another bill that I was unsure of how I was going to be able to pay. I prayed over it, and felt God say that it was taken care of. I sent the insurance company a letter, explaining my situation, and asked if there was any way I could arrange a payment plan with them. I got a call from the office manager for the hospital, and she told me that she received my letter, but that they have no way of setting up payments. I started to say "OK I under ..." but she interrupted me and said, "I don't know why I am going to do this, because I have never done this before for anyone, but i am going to forgive your debt with our company. You don't owe us anything, and I will make sure your file is updated as paid." Mind .... blown.
There have been others as well. I asked God to take care of things for me, and He has never failed. To the contrary, He has succeeded in ways that I could never have imagined.
I have prayed to God for many other things as well, and have felt Him leading me in certain directions that I never expected.
I started reading my Bible regularly, and I have found too many times to count that I have had a problem, and that problem has an answer in what I read that same day. It is often downright astonishing. I started looking into things with the UM church, like what opportunities for service there were .... and saw things like Lay Servant, Lay Speaker, and such .... and one day I went to my Pastor with a Bible question, (as I had done a few times) and he answered it, and we got into a theological discussion, where I told him of my dream of the sinner's punishment, and he said to me, out of the blue, that he wanted me to take the classes for Lay Servant and Speaker. We had never discussed it. I had never expressed a desire to do such a thing. You can call it coincidence, but I feel that God set me in a certain direction.
I don't believe that God always answers with words. He also does not always give me what I want, or ask for. Sometimes he gives me something completely different, and sometimes something so much better that I never even considered it.
Anyway, I have found that the deeper in my faith I have gone, the more often these "incredible coincidences" happen. I think that God speaks in a variety of ways, and get His point across quite well, when He wants to.
I also know that it has happened more and more frequently as I have given myself over to Him more and more, and as I have studied His Holy Word more and more.
My intent was never to get into a debate with you about whether and which God exists, bible passages, or any of that. My point was that most people (and this includes many Christians-in-name-only who don't go to church, don't read the Bible, and make no effort to follow Jesus's teachings) have experiences that are more similar to mine than they are to yours. So if you try to get someone to change their behavior because that is what your interpretation of what God wants, the vast majority will just kind of roll their eyes at you. There has to be at least some tangible benefit to society and ideally to the individual as well (if you want people to actually change their behavior).
I believe that the reason people have experiences that are closer to yours is that they do not give themselves over to God. They offer lip service to asking for forgiveness, and so forth, but live lives that are identical to every other hell bound sinner. They make no attempt to serve God. They place their lives, and their sins, above God, and so God shuts them off. Why would God waste His time on someone who is going to do things in such a way that it leads others astray? Why give the sinner a miracle, then they flaunt their sins in God's face? God wants all of us, not just a little bit. He doesn't want us to "stick a toe in" and see how the water is, He wants us to jump in head first, and trust Him. Speaking for myself, I could feel my faith growing more and more and I got into God's Word on a daily basis. I started reading the Bible every single day, and sometimes 2 or 3 times/day. I found answers to my problems and questions appearing with remarkable regularity, and clarity. You have to take the steps to come to God. He could force you to do so ..... that would be well within the powers of the One who created everything ..... but He wants us to choose Him. He wants us to want to be with Him, and to Love Him. He wants us to rely upon Him for everything. If we accept Christ as our Lord and Savior, and turn our lives over to Him, then He helps us in ways we cannot imagine. However, sometimes the ways God chooses are not the things we asked for. Using the company I spoke of above as an example, in that case I asked God for help, and wanted a payment plan. God took care of the whole thing. God can do amazing things when we let Him. We run into problems when we decide that we know better than the immortal, omniscient God who created us all.
As far as interpretations of what God wants, the Bible is really clear on most things. In the early days, after leaving Eden, God wanted us to love and obey Him, and trust in Him for salvation. However, man thought differently, and in their arrogance, told God that they wanted rules to follow so that they could do it for themselves. So, God gave us the 10 Commandments, knowing that it was a perfect Law for imperfect beings, and using it to show us that we cannot hope to be sanctified by the Law. None of us can be. All God wanted was for us to come to Him, and ask for His help. Of course, those people, like people today, were prideful, and unwilling to accept that they cannot do everything for themselves, so they continued to try the Law, and continued to fail.
As far as the Law, the 10 Commandments, the reason that God gave us these Laws, is because they are good for us. Every single one of the Laws is beneficial for man. I would argue that each one is more beneficial for man than their opposite. However, people will roll their eyes at that too. People have been rolling their eyes at God, and willfully disobeying Him since the beginning of recorded history. It is no surprise that it continues today. However, God still loves us, and still wants us to be with Him, in fellowship, and in love and peace and joy. However, we have to choose it, and the way we choose it is to turn our lives over to Almighty God, who created us and everything else in the universe. We can choose otherwise, and God will never force us to choose Him, but when we choose otherwise, we are asking God to just leave us alone. So, He does. He doesn't force any of us to come to Him. It is always our choice.
I am not going to quote the rest. You have some nice ideas as far as how people should act, but what reason do they have to do so, if not God? They can choose to behave, but they often get the things they want far easier by not behaving as we might wish.
I believe that this world is a fallen, evil world. We have people in it who love evil, and who worship evil. They worship their lusts. They worship power. They worship money. They covet everything other people have. They not only want everything, but they want it today. They lie about their friends, co-workers, neighbors, and anyone else they can think of. If thoughts could kill, many would be murderers many times over. Evil is running rampant in this world today. "Easy sin" is the prime motivator. Far to often, instead of making a stand against these sinful actions and attitudes, we just fade back, and fit in. Many tell us that we don't dare bring faith into the public arena, saying that it has no place there. If there is one thing we need more of today it is faith in Jesus Christ, and the saving atonement of the cross.
I definitely agree with you about the way many people who call themselves Christians look at their faith these days ..... with some lukewarm faith, that is there as long as it is convenient, and doesn't get in the way of the rest of their lives .....
When we look at the lives of 2 people, one supposedly a Christian, and the other an atheist secularist, and we cannot tell the difference in any observable way, then I agree, there is a major problem. I truly fear that there are going to be a lot fo Christians who are going to be horribly surprised on Judgement Day, when Jesus does just as He promised, and spits them out for being lukewarm. Jesus doesn't want "almost saved" people. He wants people on fire with their Faith, and who want others to have what they have. I know that I drive some people nuts on this board, but I want them to truly know God, and I want them to be saved. The world encourages, and drives people in the direction opposite of God. What the world offers ends the very moment we draw our final breath, whether that is in 50 years, or 5 seconds. God offers us everything good, through Jesus Christ. It's all paid for, all we have to do is choose to accept it.
Let me add that I appreciate the opportunity to discuss this with you in a civil manner.