I ws at the game. He was moving like a gimp after half.

I don't think the Dr's are lying, nor Baker. Dr's aren't saying the guy is 100% or 75%. They are simply saying there is no serious physical reason he can't play. As an example, a player could play on a sprained ankle, but he might not play well.

I think in general players are one of two types. Anything less than 100% is a problem, or they think nothing is a problem that can impact their play. I think the coach is the one who needs to tell a player, no, you are not playing this week no matter what you or the Dr's say.