This is such a weird argument.

Berry had two choices...1. Trade him now and get something for him. 2. Let him play out the season and walk after.

Neither choice was wrong. Unless you believe trading DPJ will prevent the Browns from winning the Super Bowl. I would rather wait and have this argument after Tillman drops a go ahead TD that knock the Browns out of the playoffs. Then argue to your hearts content that DPJ would have caught it.

Otherwise it's a pretty big non issue.