Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
#2146393 10/26/26 11:25 AM
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Just imagine if next year we draft Jeremiah Smith from Ohio State as our #1 WR. I would take him over any of the QBs in this upcoming draft. Smith #1, Boston #2, KC #3 AKA Slot, and at Fannon TE would be the best receiving corps in the NFL BY FAR. Oh, and btw Q and Samson can catch the ball too. Smith would make our offense so much better than any QB because of that qualitative leap when none of our WRs can be double and triple teamed.

I think Jeremiah is so good I would trade both our number 1 picks this year and maybe even next years number 1 to move up to grab him. I would normally never do that for a WR but I think he is worth it to go from a good WR corps to an elite and possibly best wr corps in all of football. I think with wrs like that any decent QB can do great things. My only fear is that the Titans will take him first to reunite him with Tate. I know if I were the TItans it's what I would do.

My only fear in making this happen is that we need to draft an elite CB and RT. This year we have the picks to make that happen but are there players worth the picks? If we can't move up to get Smith then that is what I would want to do most. CBs are so hard for me to evaluate that I have no clue if there will be an elite one we even have a chance at. Anyone know of some top tier cbs to keep an eye on?

What do my fellow Dawg fans think? What to join my Jeremiah Smith Bandwagon?


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 28,462
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 28,462
I've been thinking this since Week 2. Imagine if we can get him and somehow solve the QB question?!


Browns is the Browns

... there goes Joe Thomas, the best there ever was in this game.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,044
M
Legend
Offline
Legend
M
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,044
I've only seen highlights and read the press. He's written about in terms of a true generational talent... Randy Moss type talent.... AJ Green type talent. I think he's likely to be the 1st of the board come April.


The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,530
F
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
F
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,530
Originally Posted by mgh888
I've only seen highlights and read the press. He's written about in terms of a true generational talent... Randy Moss type talent.... AJ Green type talent. I think he's likely to be the 1st of the board come April.

He seems more physical than AJ Green to me. He looks more muscular, in line with Moss & Josh Gordon. He is very, very fast and is used to getting mugged on 25% of his receptions.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 19,289
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 19,289
Originally Posted by FORTBROWNFAN
Originally Posted by mgh888
I've only seen highlights and read the press. He's written about in terms of a true generational talent... Randy Moss type talent.... AJ Green type talent. I think he's likely to be the 1st of the board come April.

He seems more physical than AJ Green to me. He looks more muscular, in line with Moss & Josh Gordon. He is very, very fast and is used to getting mugged on 25% of his receptions.

He's Josh Gordon with a good head. Every single game he does something that will drop your jaw.....double and triple coverage, and you're absolutely right about getting mugged. The damn refs won't call a PI on him for some reason. He hasn't had one called since halfway thru his freshman season. There's also no drama at all with JS. According to all of his coaches and team mates, he's the hardest worker on the team. He's also had 3yrs of NFL caliber coaching. Sad thing is that I don't think we have a chance of landing him it will take a very high pick to bundle. Unfortunately the Rams next 3 games are against the Chargers, Commanders and Cardinals.


And into the forest I go, to lose my mind and find my soul.
- John Muir

#GMSTRONG
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
If the season continues to play out, there is no way Smith will be available even for a trade up. He will be in Los Angeles after the first pick is turned in.

Right now, the top 5 picks have 4 teams that already have their QB in place.

1 Chargers
2 Titans
4 Commanders
5 Texans

Smith will be snatched and at least 2 of the other spots will be trade ups for QBs

IF it remains the same, which I don't expect it to...

Right now the Browns currently hold #14 and a playoff spot, so lower than 20.

With every Rams win, it is going to become more difficult to move up for the QB we covet...whomever that may be.

Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I remember when Calvin Johnson came out.

Smith is similar. Not often a receiver is the first pick.

I don't think we have a chance to get him. We are going to be too far down in the draft order. Teams are not going to trade out if he is there when they pick.

The 2027 draft will be complicated for many reasons.

We are just going to have to wait to see when we pick.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
I watched the screen pass against Maryland. Should have been a 3 yard gain. It took two more watches to see that none of the three would-be tacklers even laid a finger on him on the way to the endzone.

My son said "that's the best player in college football".

I said, "Jeremiah Smith is the best football player in the world right now."

Who's better?


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Originally Posted by jfanent
He's Josh Gordon with a good head. Every single game he does something that will drop your jaw.....double and triple coverage, and you're absolutely right about getting mugged. The damn refs won't call a PI on him for some reason. He hasn't had one called since halfway thru his freshman season. There's also no drama at all with JS. According to all of his coaches and team mates, he's the hardest worker on the team. He's also had 3yrs of NFL caliber coaching. Sad thing is that I don't think we have a chance of landing him it will take a very high pick to bundle. Unfortunately the Rams next 3 games are against the Chargers, Commanders and Cardinals.




HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Right now, the top 5 picks have 4 teams that already have their QB in place.

1 Chargers
2 Titans
4 Commanders
5 Texans

I know it's still early, but that's a wild stat.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
So since we all agree that he is generational talent is both our first round picks this year and our first from next year worth a trade up to go get him and have the best WR corps in the NFL worth it?


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
So since we all agree that he is generational talent is both our first round picks this year and our first from next year worth a trade up to go get him and have the best WR corps in the NFL worth it?

I haven't seen everyone agree with that.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
So since we all agree that he is generational talent is both our first round picks this year and our first from next year worth a trade up to go get him and have the best WR corps in the NFL worth it?

1) There are 20-some teams in the league with the same mentality, so it's too hard to predict the price right now.

2) No, not if I'm GM. We're on a trajectory to have one of the best corps in the league already. You can only throw so many balls per game; how 'bout someone to do the throwin'?


Any top team that has a QB will likely not trade that pick. Any top team that needs one, won't mortgage the chance.

If Smith goes to a team via trade, it will be an absolute King's Ransom. I wouldn't do that, either would Berry.


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 16,542
M
Legend
Offline
Legend
M
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 16,542
Originally Posted by FATE
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
So since we all agree that he is generational talent is both our first round picks this year and our first from next year worth a trade up to go get him and have the best WR corps in the NFL worth it?

1) There are 20-some teams in the league with the same mentality, so it's too hard to predict the price right now.

2) No, not if I'm GM. We're on a trajectory to have one of the best corps in the league already. You can only throw so many balls per game; how 'bout someone to do the throwin'?


Any top team that has a QB will likely not trade that pick. Any top team that needs one, won't mortgage the chance.

If Smith goes to a team via trade, it will be an absolute King's Ransom. I wouldn't do that, either would Berry.

Plus, "generational talent" gets thrown around every other week. Smith is an absolute beast, but throwing multiple first round picks at a WR is a bit aggressive.

Another absolute beast is true freshman, Jesse Legree (Oregon State). He is absolutely shredding defenses and didn't even start playing WR until his senior year in HS. He was a DB that converted to WR. Fun player to watch.

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
There are not many WRs you will ever hear me say are generational but come on Smith is easily one of them. He is the best WR in college and I don't think it's even close. Size, speed, techniqal, hands, etc he has it all. I don't see any real weaknesses in his play.

I could even see him going number 1 overall and not even be available to trade up for. I would happily trade 3 first round picks to land him and make our WR corps the best in football. Boston is not a real number 1 WR. He is a very good number 2 with KC being the perfect slot wr. Having Smith would make both of them basically unstoppable.

I feel you guys on not having a great QB on this team to throw to them but having great wrs can make an average QB play at a good level. Sanders especially relies on having WRs who fight for the ball or come back to the ball. I think with smith and boston Sanders could be a good enough QB for us for a long time. I also think Green could easily be a solution at QB with monken teaching him and letting him develop in the background. The Browns obviously think highly of Green since they won't risk putting him on the practice squad.

I do get the argument for not using 3 first round picks though. I just think Smith is the best WR to come along in a long, long time. I personally would happily trade 3 firsts for a WR of his level Since I don't really care for the QBs coming out these days. Like QBs coming out these days are just dumb when it comes to being able to read defenses and it's just not worth the high draft capital anymore IMHO. They are all being molded into athletic 1 read QBs because college teams have to start them or they leave through the portal instead of developing them.

So since QBs are all going to be average at best then I would rather build an elite WR corps to create easy throws to score points. Great WRs create places to throw instead of waiting to be thrown open.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Travis Hunter is the name that last popped up as a "generational player".


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Travis is looking amazing at CB. I think we won that trade atm but I would have loved to have him.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Generational talent means much more than being an amazing CB. And I think the term "amazing" in regards to Travis Hunter as a CB is a stretch. After week 7 PFF has him ranked as the 22nd ranked CB.

https://www.pff.com/grades/nfl/cb

Certainly a very good CB. Certainly as asset to any teams secondary. But let's not get carried away.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
Travis Hunter is the name that last popped up as a "generational player".

Yes, but he wasn't a generational CB or WR... He was a generational athlete...
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
There are not many WRs you will ever hear me say are generational but come on Smith is easily one of them. He is the best WR in college and I don't think it's even close. Size, speed, techniqal, hands, etc he has it all. I don't see any real weaknesses in his play.

I could even see him going number 1 overall and not even be available to trade up for. I would happily trade 3 first round picks to land him and make our WR corps the best in football. Boston is not a real number 1 WR. He is a very good number 2 with KC being the perfect slot wr. Having Smith would make both of them basically unstoppable.

I feel you guys on not having a great QB on this team to throw to them but having great wrs can make an average QB play at a good level. Sanders especially relies on having WRs who fight for the ball or come back to the ball. I think with smith and boston Sanders could be a good enough QB for us for a long time. I also think Green could easily be a solution at QB with monken teaching him and letting him develop in the background. The Browns obviously think highly of Green since they won't risk putting him on the practice squad.

I do get the argument for not using 3 first round picks though. I just think Smith is the best WR to come along in a long, long time. I personally would happily trade 3 firsts for a WR of his level Since I don't really care for the QBs coming out these days. Like QBs coming out these days are just dumb when it comes to being able to read defenses and it's just not worth the high draft capital anymore IMHO. They are all being molded into athletic 1 read QBs because college teams have to start them or they leave through the portal instead of developing them.

So since QBs are all going to be average at best then I would rather build an elite WR corps to create easy throws to score points. Great WRs create places to throw instead of waiting to be thrown open.

So, I have some fundamental flaws with the plan.

1) I don't think Sanders is a 4500 yard per year QB. It doesn't matter the number of sockets you have in the set if the wrench is broken. Until the Browns build an offensive line capable of 150 yards rushing per game. Teams will find ways to neutralize the receivers without competence at QB. It takes a live arm to utilize guys like Smith, Boston and Concepcion.

2) Green isn't "that" guy. He is built more to make things happen, a poor man's Lamar. If you want the guy who will help get you to the 150 yards rushing per game, you aren't going to need an over load of WRs.

3) If neither 1. or 2. above are your answer at QB, giving up (3) first rounders for one guy that doesn't have the one tool he needs in place to succeed isn't just wasting his career, it's wasting the other two POSITIONS that you might have filled with the extra guys you gave up. I think we can all agree we are going to need help in the very near future at CB, EDGE and O-Line. We can keep filling those holes with 3rd rounders... but then we will continue talking about what are we going to do to upgrade the position.

QBs are not a dime a dozen, it is the most important position on a football team and it isn't close. Spending capital on someone you are convinced could fix the position for the next 15 years is a plan worth executing. Spending (3) firsts in a WR, where there are examples of really good players, and they actually become available in free agency on a regular basis as well, in my humble opinion is not.

Now, if the Rams pick ends up in the top (3) and two QBs go 1-2 and he is sitting there. THEN it depends on that QB we've all been discussing... Is one of the first two taken your guy, or is he still sitting there. If he's there, take him. If he is gone, I would LOVE to have Smith in a Browns uniform in the hopes that you can make magic happen with other picks in either this or the next draft to get an upgrade at QB... not in the 5th round mind you, someone WORTHY of a high draft pick.

Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Let's do an experiment with arguably one of the 2 best WRs in NFL history, Randy Moss

1998 1313/17
1999 1413/11
2000 1437/15
2001 1233/10
2002 1347/7
2003 1362/17
2004 767/13 injured, still managed to score TDs
2005 1005/8
2006 553/3
2007 1493/23
2008 1008/11
2009 1264/13

Now, the QBs throwing him the ball:
1998 Brad Johnson / Randall Cunningham
1999 Randall Cuninham / Jeff George
2000 Daunte Culpepper
2001 Daunte Culpepper / Todd Bowman
2002 Daunte Culpepper
2003 Daunte Culpepper / Gus Frerotte
2004 Daunte Culpepper
2005 Kerry Collins / Marques Tuiasosopo
2006 Andrew Walter / Aaron Brooks
2007 Tom Brady
2008 Matt Cassell
2009 Tom Brady

YES, he was one of the two best WRs to ever play the game... however, two years in 2006 and 2008, he had Shedeur Sanders type QBs and he looked average...


We NEED a QB, we WANT a generational WR. I am good with a perennial top 8-10 QB, I don't need he next hall of famer to come out of college. Those guys make a Denzel Boston into #1 receivers. Boston has everything needed to be a leader at his position, except a QB.

Anyone that says Boston isn't a Ja'Maar Chase better follow up with, but he doesn't have a Joe Burrow.

Last edited by IrishDawg42; 10/28/26 04:58 PM.
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 2,295
B
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
B
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 2,295
Irish, it's funny; over the history of the NFL, it's the team that makes the QB.

Very few drafted a QB and then built around him. Most either drafted a QB they believed fit their team or developed one.

In my opinion, the Browns are in an ideal situation. They'll fall somewhere in the middle of the draft, and some kid who played for an average team will be there. He has all the mental and physical skills, but he had the misfortune of playing for a mediocre team.

I was hoping Mendoza somehow fell to the Browns, but Indiana spoiled it by winning the championship!

Fans haven't figured out that great QBs don't come with all the attributes. It takes a team with the right chemistry and stability to produce their guy. Shedeur could be that guy. Who's to say where his development lands by next year? For you old-timers, how did Brian Sipe become the guy?

More often than not, good teams know how to pick their guy! Yes, the Browns failed on their picks. Then again, have they been experimenting with who qualifies or what criteria are needed?

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 28,462
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 28,462
::looks at our QB position::

Well, we've made worse choices with three first rounders.


Browns is the Browns

... there goes Joe Thomas, the best there ever was in this game.

Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Originally Posted by bugs
Irish, it's funny; over the history of the NFL, it's the team that makes the QB.

Very few drafted a QB and then built around him. Most either drafted a QB they believed fit their team or developed one.

In my opinion, the Browns are in an ideal situation. They'll fall somewhere in the middle of the draft, and some kid who played for an average team will be there. He has all the mental and physical skills, but he had the misfortune of playing for a mediocre team.

I was hoping Mendoza somehow fell to the Browns, but Indiana spoiled it by winning the championship!

Fans haven't figured out that great QBs don't come with all the attributes. It takes a team with the right chemistry and stability to produce their guy. Shedeur could be that guy. Who's to say where his development lands by next year? For you old-timers, how did Brian Sipe become the guy?

More often than not, good teams know how to pick their guy! Yes, the Browns failed on their picks. Then again, have they been experimenting with who qualifies or what criteria are needed?

I agree. I'm not implying to get rid of all the talent because you are looking for a QB. I'm saying all that talent will go to waste if you don't have a QB.

As an old timer(GenX, so don't test me. We aren't as polite as the boomers), I loved the 1980 season watching Brian Sipe. Sipe had a couple of good years out of a ten year career. It was never about Brian Sipe, he took the accolades for players like Mike Pruitt, Greg Pruitt(past his prime), Hall of Famer Ozzie Newsome, Reggie Rucker, Dave Logan. That was a fun offense and an even better defense. They had 22 INTs that year and 10 more fumble recoveries. It made it a little easier for the team to score points. It was one of the most fun seasons I've seen in my life time.

Regardless of all the Super Bowl era Super Stars you can come up with.. Bernie Kosar for example.. NONE have gotten this team to the big game, let alone win it. It's going to take a special team, and I think we have a damn good base right now. We need the guy to lead them there, I can't say Sanders can't be the guy, I'm just saying he hasn't done anything to look like that guy in his career. I don't know why people are putting any eggs in that basket. I wish he was because I like the kid.

I don't want to draft a QB and then start building around him. We've thankfully already started the build, hell we are knee deep in the build. In order to have this team ready for the dome opening, we need to draft a guy now that is worthy of a first round pick. Doesn't have to be worthy of the #1 overall, but a first round grade is what I am talking about.

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Let's do an experiment with arguably one of the 2 best WRs in NFL history, Randy Moss

1998 1313/17
1999 1413/11
2000 1437/15
2001 1233/10
2002 1347/7
2003 1362/17
2004 767/13 injured, still managed to score TDs
2005 1005/8
2006 553/3
2007 1493/23
2008 1008/11
2009 1264/13

Now, the QBs throwing him the ball:
1998 Brad Johnson / Randall Cunningham
1999 Randall Cuninham / Jeff George
2000 Daunte Culpepper
2001 Daunte Culpepper / Todd Bowman
2002 Daunte Culpepper
2003 Daunte Culpepper / Gus Frerotte
2004 Daunte Culpepper
2005 Kerry Collins / Marques Tuiasosopo
2006 Andrew Walter / Aaron Brooks
2007 Tom Brady
2008 Matt Cassell
2009 Tom Brady

YES, he was one of the two best WRs to ever play the game... however, two years in 2006 and 2008, he had Shedeur Sanders type QBs and he looked average...


We NEED a QB, we WANT a generational WR. I am good with a perennial top 8-10 QB, I don't need he next hall of famer to come out of college. Those guys make a Denzel Boston into #1 receivers. Boston has everything needed to be a leader at his position, except a QB.

Anyone that says Boston isn't a Ja'Maar Chase better follow up with, but he doesn't have a Joe Burrow.

Randy Moss had several injuries in 2006 and in 2008 Brady was injured and the backup QB was meh. You might want a great QB but are there any to be had? I don't think so. That's the problem. There are only a bunch of so-so QBs to be had and any we draft will take YEARS to develop most likely due to how the college game has changed. Hell Burrows is considered an elite QB but even he doesn't get 4500 yards often. Poor Burrows can't stay healthy. Which just shows it's better to build around avg qbs who are cap friendly and give them great weapons to work with. Would Burrow be so great if he didn't have 2 of the best WRs in the game? Probably not. How good was Joe Montana without Jerry Rice? He became average. It takes a great WR to make a good QB shine.

I love Boston but he is more like a T-Higgens than a Jamar Chase. Boston is that tough WR who will fight for balls but doesn't have elite speed. Boston would explode when they can't put double and triple teams on him. That is the thing about a true #1 WR. They draw the double and triple teams that open the rest of the offense up. Running gets easier because they can't stack the line. TEs become deadly when there is no one left to cover them.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
Travis Hunter is the name that last popped up as a "generational player".

Yes, but he wasn't a generational CB or WR... He was a generational athlete...
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
There are not many WRs you will ever hear me say are generational but come on Smith is easily one of them. He is the best WR in college and I don't think it's even close. Size, speed, techniqal, hands, etc he has it all. I don't see any real weaknesses in his play.

I could even see him going number 1 overall and not even be available to trade up for. I would happily trade 3 first round picks to land him and make our WR corps the best in football. Boston is not a real number 1 WR. He is a very good number 2 with KC being the perfect slot wr. Having Smith would make both of them basically unstoppable.

I feel you guys on not having a great QB on this team to throw to them but having great wrs can make an average QB play at a good level. Sanders especially relies on having WRs who fight for the ball or come back to the ball. I think with smith and boston Sanders could be a good enough QB for us for a long time. I also think Green could easily be a solution at QB with monken teaching him and letting him develop in the background. The Browns obviously think highly of Green since they won't risk putting him on the practice squad.

I do get the argument for not using 3 first round picks though. I just think Smith is the best WR to come along in a long, long time. I personally would happily trade 3 firsts for a WR of his level Since I don't really care for the QBs coming out these days. Like QBs coming out these days are just dumb when it comes to being able to read defenses and it's just not worth the high draft capital anymore IMHO. They are all being molded into athletic 1 read QBs because college teams have to start them or they leave through the portal instead of developing them.

So since QBs are all going to be average at best then I would rather build an elite WR corps to create easy throws to score points. Great WRs create places to throw instead of waiting to be thrown open.

So, I have some fundamental flaws with the plan.

1) I don't think Sanders is a 4500 yard per year QB. It doesn't matter the number of sockets you have in the set if the wrench is broken. Until the Browns build an offensive line capable of 150 yards rushing per game. Teams will find ways to neutralize the receivers without competence at QB. It takes a live arm to utilize guys like Smith, Boston and Concepcion.

2) Green isn't "that" guy. He is built more to make things happen, a poor man's Lamar. If you want the guy who will help get you to the 150 yards rushing per game, you aren't going to need an over load of WRs.

3) If neither 1. or 2. above are your answer at QB, giving up (3) first rounders for one guy that doesn't have the one tool he needs in place to succeed isn't just wasting his career, it's wasting the other two POSITIONS that you might have filled with the extra guys you gave up. I think we can all agree we are going to need help in the very near future at CB, EDGE and O-Line. We can keep filling those holes with 3rd rounders... but then we will continue talking about what are we going to do to upgrade the position.

QBs are not a dime a dozen, it is the most important position on a football team and it isn't close. Spending capital on someone you are convinced could fix the position for the next 15 years is a plan worth executing. Spending (3) firsts in a WR, where there are examples of really good players, and they actually become available in free agency on a regular basis as well, in my humble opinion is not.

Now, if the Rams pick ends up in the top (3) and two QBs go 1-2 and he is sitting there. THEN it depends on that QB we've all been discussing... Is one of the first two taken your guy, or is he still sitting there. If he's there, take him. If he is gone, I would LOVE to have Smith in a Browns uniform in the hopes that you can make magic happen with other picks in either this or the next draft to get an upgrade at QB... not in the 5th round mind you, someone WORTHY of a high draft pick.

I just want to thank you for your detailed response even if I don't agree with everything. I just love to see good arguments.

1)I don't think Sanders is a 4500 yard per year QB either. Then again neither is Burrows. Could we get a reliable 3500 yards if we draft Smith though? Yes, and very easily so. Sanders has the ability to throw the ball well. He just has to speed up his decision making and at the end of last year he was starting to show that it was possible.

2)I agree that Green is a poor man's Lamar. The thing is, Lamar was not so great either until Monken taught him how to be a better passer. Sadly Lamar doesn't seem to be able to stay healthy. I see Green as more of a Kordell Stewart role myself and think he would be great for that. Sanders as the starter and Green as his back up. I would love to see Green become the holder for the field goal kicker. A fake field goal where he takes off is scary with his speed.

3) Tell me what Elite QB we are going to draft in the next two years when we are making the playoffs? We won't be. Maybe LA's pick turns into gold but I doubt they keep losing once Myles recovers from his surgery as it was only a knee scope to clean up his knee. So in reality we are not drafting a great QB anytime soon. We just aren't. Any good ones if there are any will be taken long before we can pick him up and teams seldom trade down from picking a QB.

QBs are not even a nickel a dozen anymore. All I see in the last several years are a bunch of bleh. None of them seem that exciting to me. Are there any you like that you think are worth passing on the best WR to come out in at least a decade like Smith? I just don't see anyone worth passing him up or believe we would have the draft capital to land said QB. Hell, I am not even sure if Smith doesn't become the number 1 overall pick and becomes impossible for us to trade up and get. I just want Smith because I think he would elevate our offense to an elite level even with Sanders throwing him the ball or God forbid ... Watson throwing him the ball.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by PrplPplEater
::looks at our QB position::

Well, we've made worse choices with three first rounders.

LOL! True that!


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Originally Posted by bugs
Irish, it's funny; over the history of the NFL, it's the team that makes the QB.

Very few drafted a QB and then built around him. Most either drafted a QB they believed fit their team or developed one.

In my opinion, the Browns are in an ideal situation. They'll fall somewhere in the middle of the draft, and some kid who played for an average team will be there. He has all the mental and physical skills, but he had the misfortune of playing for a mediocre team.

I was hoping Mendoza somehow fell to the Browns, but Indiana spoiled it by winning the championship!

Fans haven't figured out that great QBs don't come with all the attributes. It takes a team with the right chemistry and stability to produce their guy. Shedeur could be that guy. Who's to say where his development lands by next year? For you old-timers, how did Brian Sipe become the guy?

More often than not, good teams know how to pick their guy! Yes, the Browns failed on their picks. Then again, have they been experimenting with who qualifies or what criteria are needed?

I agree. I'm not implying to get rid of all the talent because you are looking for a QB. I'm saying all that talent will go to waste if you don't have a QB.

As an old timer(GenX, so don't test me. We aren't as polite as the boomers), I loved the 1980 season watching Brian Sipe. Sipe had a couple of good years out of a ten year career. It was never about Brian Sipe, he took the accolades for players like Mike Pruitt, Greg Pruitt(past his prime), Hall of Famer Ozzie Newsome, Reggie Rucker, Dave Logan. That was a fun offense and an even better defense. They had 22 INTs that year and 10 more fumble recoveries. It made it a little easier for the team to score points. It was one of the most fun seasons I've seen in my life time.

Regardless of all the Super Bowl era Super Stars you can come up with.. Bernie Kosar for example.. NONE have gotten this team to the big game, let alone win it. It's going to take a special team, and I think we have a damn good base right now. We need the guy to lead them there, I can't say Sanders can't be the guy, I'm just saying he hasn't done anything to look like that guy in his career. I don't know why people are putting any eggs in that basket. I wish he was because I like the kid.

I don't want to draft a QB and then start building around him. We've thankfully already started the build, hell we are knee deep in the build. In order to have this team ready for the dome opening, we need to draft a guy now that is worthy of a first round pick. Doesn't have to be worthy of the #1 overall, but a first round grade is what I am talking about.

I think you both make good points. We grew up in an NFL where elite QBs ruled. But look at the NFL now. Very few elite QBs. I don't think any of the elite QBs we have now are nearly as good as the elites of the past especially if you put staying healthy as a requirement. I honestly don't know if Sanders can be THE GUY. I just really like him as a human being and I am rooting for him. I just have this gut feeling he is going to be a Joe Montana type QB who uses charisma and moxy to will the team to win. Give him some great talent and see where he goes. If he doesn't get it done then sign a veteran QB to an obscene contract while we have lots of young talent on offense. We only have about a 3 to 5 year window to figure this thing out before the defense starts to age and we fall into CB hell. That's why I take Smith and have a young elite receiving corps that ANY QB can be great with. Honestly with that WR corps with Smith as our Number 1 WR I genuinely think Sanders will tear the league up.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Shedeur in my mind still has to prove that he can play in the NFL.

There really cannot be speculation. Some thought he was a first round talent. NFL teams did not think so.

He has started seven games. The sample size is too small to determine what he can do.

He has to prove it on the field when he gets his chance. At some point that chance will come. He has been in the NFL and is getting the opportunity to learn. It is up to him to take advantage of that opportunity.

I think the Browns need to be patient with him. Ignore the noise. Develop him.

When he gets his chance. We shall see.

The 2027 draft order is still to be determined. If we get a chance to draft a quarterback who we value at the slot we draft. Draft him.

Let the most talented player rise to be the starter.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
Just imagine if next year we draft Jeremiah Smith from Ohio State as our #1 WR. I would take him over any of the QBs in this upcoming draft. Smith #1, Boston #2, KC #3 AKA Slot, and at Fannon TE would be the best receiving corps in the NFL BY FAR. Oh, and btw Q and Samson can catch the ball too. Smith would make our offense so much better than any QB because of that qualitative leap when none of our WRs can be double and triple teamed.

I think Jeremiah is so good I would trade both our number 1 picks this year and maybe even next years number 1 to move up to grab him. I would normally never do that for a WR but I think he is worth it to go from a good WR corps to an elite and possibly best wr corps in all of football. I think with wrs like that any decent QB can do great things. My only fear is that the Titans will take him first to reunite him with Tate. I know if I were the TItans it's what I would do.

My only fear in making this happen is that we need to draft an elite CB and RT. This year we have the picks to make that happen but are there players worth the picks? If we can't move up to get Smith then that is what I would want to do most. CBs are so hard for me to evaluate that I have no clue if there will be an elite one we even have a chance at. Anyone know of some top tier cbs to keep an eye on?

What do my fellow Dawg fans think? What to join my Jeremiah Smith Bandwagon?

Just imagine: If frogs had wings, they could fly.

I doubt the 5 wins we already have is going to put us in to a position to draft the guy, so why imagine? We won't be able to draft him and if Berry trades the farm for the guy, I might shoot myself*.

* Not really, just a figure of speech to emphasize the point.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
"We don't have a legitimate QB moving forward into 2027."

"Hey! Let's sell the farm for a WR!"

Who'da thunk it?


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
I've heard (probably on here) the theory that our new direction is likely that of building an offensive roster that doesn't need a top-tier QB to win.

While getting a talent like JS certainly fits well into that strategy, spending up to 3 firsts does not... especially when it's becoming more and more clear that additional investment in the Oline is needed.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 2,295
B
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
B
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 2,295
Razor, a true question. Why do we need Jeremiah Smith?

Yes, I don't deny Jeremiah is a generational WR talent. Yes, Jeremiah would be an asset. BUT, at what cost?

The question becomes: how much does Jeremiah bring to the table compared to what Boston and/or Concepcion provide? Two, what are you doing to sign the receivers to a second contract?

It really boils down to whether you keep Boston and Concepcion or keep Jeremiah. Then, in order to keep Jeremiah, you must consistently bring in rookie talent to complement Smith.

As much as I want Jeremiah, I don't see the cost-benefit.

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by bugs
Razor, a true question. Why do we need Jeremiah Smith?

Yes, I don't deny Jeremiah is a generational WR talent. Yes, Jeremiah would be an asset. BUT, at what cost?

The question becomes: how much does Jeremiah bring to the table compared to what Boston and/or Concepcion provide? Two, what are you doing to sign the receivers to a second contract?

It really boils down to whether you keep Boston and Concepcion or keep Jeremiah. Then, in order to keep Jeremiah, you must consistently bring in rookie talent to complement Smith.

As much as I want Jeremiah, I don't see the cost-benefit.

Fair questions. I don't see Boston as a true number 1 WR but as an elite number 2 wr. Boston will do much much better as a wr with a WR like Smith as the true number 1 WR. I wasn't a big fan of KC before the draft and I am still not a big fan of him. He only had a nice game against Ten because they smothered Boston and Fannon. When teams but a decent CB with long arms on KC he just disappears. I do think KC makes a decent slot receiver but he is not impressive as a number 2 wr. Smith is that guy that completes the puzzle and turns the offense from good potential to elite. I would be very happy with Smith, Boston, and Fannon Jr. as the must have guys on the field. I think you can lock down those 3 guys longterm now that we won't be paying for Garret and Watson(most likely). Even if Sanders pops his first contract renewal wont be massive money.

All good teams have to constantly draft young rookie talents to be successful or you can't manage the salary cap. That won't change whether we have smith or not. On the plus side Berry is showing that he can draft that talent so maybe it's doable. Either way, Smith would give our offense a real shot at being elite.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
"We don't have a legitimate QB moving forward into 2027."

"Hey! Let's sell the farm for a WR!"

Who'da thunk it?


I get it man. I do. But just because you want a QB doesn't mean there is one to be had. There are maybe 5 good QBs in the entire NFL right now. College prospects don't look great either except to say some guys have a strong arm and some can run fast. None of them look that impressive at reading defenses. Drafting based on need almost always ends up in failure.

So if you want a QB then who do you suggest we draft? I'm willing to take a flyer and look at em. I just haven't seen anything but mediocre QBs. I like Arch Manning but he isn't a cerebral QB and just falls in line with that physically gifted QB IMHO. I might be dead before Peyton Manning's kid makes it to the NFL ...

So if there is no great QB to be had ... Best Player Available is Jeremiah Smith IMHO.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by oobernoober
I've heard (probably on here) the theory that our new direction is likely that of building an offensive roster that doesn't need a top-tier QB to win.

While getting a talent like JS certainly fits well into that strategy, spending up to 3 firsts does not... especially when it's becoming more and more clear that additional investment in the Oline is needed.


That is a fair argument and I even agree with it to a point. What we need on offensive line though can be had in second round picks for the most part. I would prefer to only trade 2 first round picks to get JS. I just think JS is going to be aggressively sought after by many teams because they all know what that kind of WR talent can do for a team.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I have to disagree on KC.

IMO he is a dynamic player with short area quickness that he uses to create separation. Once he catches the ball he is a threat to take off.

Monken is doing a good job of utilizing his strength and that is getting him the ball in space. He is a YAC guy with his open field ability.

I believe he will play a big part in the Browns success for years to come.

Off the line he is hard to cover. He can be counted on to be open when they need that five yard gain for a first down or near the goal line.

He is a rookie and it takes some time for the chemistry to develop with a quarterback.

IMO as each week passes he will become more involved.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
What you are suggesting doesn't just mean we can't get our QB this year, but we can't get one next year. With currently having no legitimate QB on the roster that just doesn't make any sense. Most NCAA QB's are never "ready" the day you draft them. The college game today isn't conducive to developing a QB that way. It's not their job to get their QB NFL ready. Their job is to fit their QB into their systems. Very few pro style systems are run in the NCAA. You are asking for something you yourself knows doesn't exists. The job is to identify the NCAA QB's whose skill set fits and will transfer over to the NFL.

That's well above my pay grade.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
H
Hall of Famer
Offline
Hall of Famer
H
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
IMO, you have to draft a QB that has the physical tools to play in the NFL and also shows at least some cerebral ability to play at the next level. Yes. most College QB's aren't ready for the NFL because their coaches don't have to do that. They're trying to win at the College level. That's their job and let's face it, a lot of college coaches don't know how to coach at the NFL level.

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
That's kind of the point. There isn't going to be some great QB we draft that will be ready to play right away and no promise that they will be better than what we already have. The NFL is going into a dark ages of QB play due to the poor development at the college level. So let's not waste picks on a QB who isn't going to be much of an improvement over Sanders who is being coached up my Monken. Plus Green is also being devolved by Monkien and I actually feel Green has a LOT of potential.

Now, if the Browns can't land Smith I won't hate them for it. He might well be too expensive to trade up for. I honestly think he will end up with the TItans and I will hate every second of it.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by bonefish
I have to disagree on KC.

IMO he is a dynamic player with short area quickness that he uses to create separation. Once he catches the ball he is a threat to take off.

Monken is doing a good job of utilizing his strength and that is getting him the ball in space. He is a YAC guy with his open field ability.

I believe he will play a big part in the Browns success for years to come.

Off the line he is hard to cover. He can be counted on to be open when they need that five yard gain for a first down or near the goal line.

He is a rookie and it takes some time for the chemistry to develop with a quarterback.

IMO as each week passes he will become more involved.

I agree with you buddy. He needs a fast decision maker to hit him in the right timing window though for his skill set to shine. Watson did that this last game so I am hoping he can keep it up. Otherwise KC just gets swallowed after the adjust after his move to get open. Honestly both our rookie WRs are playing far beyond what is to be expected from rookies. I'm not hating on KC. I like the kid. It's just I think he would shine a lot more as a pure slot receiver which Monken LOVES to use aka Jay Flowers. I think with Smith and Boston as the number 1 and 2 KC would be so hard to cover. Any QB we have is going to look like a stud with that kind of wr line up.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Even though KC and Boston are rookies I could not be more encouraged.

These two are the best young receivers in my memory.

In addition I believe Fannin is a complete stud. He is a monster after the catch. Those three guys could develop into weapons of mass destruction.

I don't know where this whole DW thing will end up. I thought he was going bomb this year. So, on that note I was dead wrong.

I didn't think he had it in him mentally or physically.

So, for now it is a week to week thing. He is trending upward. It is obvious he is gaining confidence. He is playing under control instead of panic.

I do know where this will go? You would think he will improve as chemistry develops.

This game will test him. Looks like Howard will be out. So, that leaves Jones on Watt.

Man, I want this game bad.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
So let's not waste picks on a QB who isn't going to be much of an improvement over Sanders who is being coached up my Monken. Plus Green is also being devolved by Monkien and I actually feel Green has a LOT of potential.

You are trying to compare the odds of success of a bona fide first round pick at QB to late round flyer picks at the QB position as somehow being similar. That defies any form of logic. I'm not sure if you just can't hear yourself or if you are just being ridiculous on purpose. This is so crazy it's not even worthy of discussion.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
I might give up a 3rd rounder plus our 1st rounder to trade up for the guy. More than that, forget it. The type of trades people are proposing are 1 player away trades, and even then I wouldn't do that for a non QB college player. Most trades like that are for a proven NFL vet. A Jeffery Simmons is a guy who can do that for a team, not a college prospect.

Simmons is a guy who can take a team from almost there, "there".


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
This question is for Razorthorn only..

Would you trade Denzel Boston, KC Conception and the higher of the two first round picks for Smith?

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
H
Hall of Famer
Offline
Hall of Famer
H
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
I think 2 first rounders were too much for Simmons. Maybe a 1st and 2nd but that's it. Although I know it's been done before, usually multiple 1st's are for a QB in a trade or to move uup in the draft. As far as a trade we know all about that don't we? frown

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
This question is for Razorthorn only..

Would you trade Denzel Boston, KC Conception and the higher of the two first round picks for Smith?


No. I would not trade Boston away period. Boston is one of my favorite type of WR types and I want him AND Smith so having smith without Boston is counter productive to me. I had Boston rated as the top WR in this past draft behind Tate that I wanted. I thought this past draft was an excellent draft for #2 WRs and slot WRs. To me these guys have already proven they are going to be stars in the NFL so I don't want to trade them. I would rather trade unproven draft picks to move up for Smith than trade away players who are already proven to be capable.

To be clear, in my mind you are offering 3 first round picks for move up for Smith since I view Boston as a first round pick we got lucky enough to draft later. BUT if you wanted to trade two firsts and a second round pick to move up and take Smith I would be all for it. I just don't want to give up Boston and KC.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
So let's not waste picks on a QB who isn't going to be much of an improvement over Sanders who is being coached up my Monken. Plus Green is also being devolved by Monkien and I actually feel Green has a LOT of potential.

You are trying to compare the odds of success of a bona fide first round pick at QB to late round flyer picks at the QB position as somehow being similar. That defies any form of logic. I'm not sure if you just can't hear yourself or if you are just being ridiculous on purpose. This is so crazy it's not even worthy of discussion.

You keep harping on drafting a QB so I asked you what QB you are going to draft that is so much better than Sanders or Watson. Teams drafting QBs in the first round based on need instead of BPA almost always end up failing because they lost a great talent for a subpar QB. A QB taken in the first round is not a guarantee to be a bonafide great QB. There are tons of first round QBs who have been complete failures but you are acting like taking one in the first round is a promise of a great QB. The Browns have taken 5 QBs in the first round since returning in 1999. How many of those 5 were worth the pick? Still think I am crazy or will you learn that drafting purely for need is a recipe for failure in the NFL?


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
The Browns will not be in a position to draft Smith.

In addition they just drafted two receivers high in the draft and they are keepers for sure.

We don't have a solution at quarterback at least one we can count on for sure.

Where we draft and who is available is unknown. The draft needs to line up and we need to evaluate correctly.

The quarterback prospects in this coming draft are uncertain. Some may return to college.

Dante Moore is out for the rest of this year. His stock may drop. Manning may return to school. His stock is questionable.

Still to early to even pick a guy to go after.

The great unknown is where we will be at the end of this season? Also what will happen with DW?

I will wait till we finish this season before I can get into who to draft and if there is a quarterback to target.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by Homewood Dog
I think 2 first rounders were too much for Simmons. Maybe a 1st and 2nd but that's it. Although I know it's been done before, usually multiple 1st's are for a QB in a trade or to move uup in the draft. As far as a trade we know all about that don't we? frown

All that matters is what the Bears thought. For the Browns, I agree. Trades like that are when you think you are 1 player away. We aren't. The Bears felt they were that 1 player away, so it made sense to them. We will find out soon enough if they made a good trade or screwed up like the Rams trading for Garrett.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Watson won't be here next year. Several QB's in this upcoming draft are valued higher than Sanders. He has shown to be nothing more than a turnover machine. I repeat............

You are trying to compare the odds of success of a bona fide first round pick at QB to late round flyer picks at the QB position as somehow being similar. That defies any form of logic. I'm not sure if you just can't hear yourself or if you are just being ridiculous on purpose. This is so crazy it's not even worthy of discussion.

Your premise presents itself much closer to a stand up comedy routine than a legitimate QB debate.

While the exact percentage fluctuates slightly week-to-week based on injuries and lineup changes, the overwhelming majority of NFL starters are premium draft assets. Historically, roughly 75% to 80% of the league's primary starting quarterbacks are former first-round picks, while second- and third-round picks make up most of the remainder.

And you response? "Yeah but what about that fifth and seventh rounder we have on the roster." I still don't think you hear yourself. rolleyes


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
And one big reason the Bears feel they are possibly just a player away is because they already have their QB. You can never get to that point until you do.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
And one big reason the Bears feel they are possibly just a player away is because they already have their QB. You can never get to that point until you do.

So who is your bonafine you want to draft Pit? I don't see one. All I see are a bunch of mediocre garbage. I don't see any elite QBs that scream we have to have this guy. Honestly, I find it hard to watch college football these days because the level of play just seems putrid anymore. The portal is flat our ruining college football to where only rich college programs are going to be able to keep any talent and smaller teams will just get striped bare. They will stop developing players because they have to win now while they have them for a year. QBs take the most time and effort to build up and why would any team bother when the second they get good they will just bail to a team that can pay them?

So I get that you WANT one. IS there one to be had especially where we will be drafting at?


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
And one big reason the Bears feel they are possibly just a player away is because they already have their QB. You can never get to that point until you do.

I might not say never, but no doubt it is a big part. If the team is good enough, I don't think you need an elite QB, but you do need a good QB.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
For the last two years Arch Manning was considered to be the crown jewel.

Royal blood a descendant of greatness.

Well the shine has come off. Where is Arch Manning as a prospect? Is the problem the head coach? Is the offensive system holding him back?

He was presumed to be the first pick in the draft. Well that boat has sailed.

Is there a silver lining?

He might be there when the Browns pick. There is no world that exists where Jimmy Haslam would not draft Manning. Jimmy could not help himself.

What I have seen of Manning is limited. I have not studied him. I have watched him for a few quarters. He showed ability and he made bad decisions.

We will not know the draft order till the season ends. Between the Rams pick and our pick maybe we are near the middle of the first round.

He could be there. That would be mind numbing.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
As I explained, there are several that are far better options than anything we will be left with on the roster after watson leaves. Even you know that. Making the claim that trying to develop a 5th and a 7th round QB while dumping three first rounders on WR is some great option is off the chains crazy.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
And one big reason the Bears feel they are possibly just a player away is because they already have their QB. You can never get to that point until you do.

So who is your bonafine you want to draft Pit? I don't see one. All I see are a bunch of mediocre garbage. I don't see any elite QBs that scream we have to have this guy. Honestly, I find it hard to watch college football these days because the level of play just seems putrid anymore. The portal is flat our ruining college football to where only rich college programs are going to be able to keep any talent and smaller teams will just get striped bare. They will stop developing players because they have to win now while they have them for a year. QBs take the most time and effort to build up and why would any team bother when the second they get good they will just bail to a team that can pay them?

So I get that you WANT one. IS there one to be had especially where we will be drafting at?
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
As I explained, there are several that are far better options than anything we will be left with on the roster after watson leaves. Even you know that. Making the claim that trying to develop a 5th and a 7th round QB while dumping three first rounders on WR is some great option is off the chains crazy.


I'm with Pit on this one..

For one, there is no arguing who you want as a replacement in November before the season is even over. Too many things have to happen between now and the draft. 1) need to know the draft order 2) evaluate which teams will be in the market for a QB, to see where the possible trade spots are 3) Need to know the list of draft committed candidates.... THEN you can start evaluating draft grades on the prospects.

To Pit's point, you are talking about replacing a 5th round pick with a possible first round grade guy... What is your train of thought here? I agree, you don't give a 3rd round grade on a guy and reach for him in the first round, but regardless of where you are in the process and wanting Smith so badly that you don't give a proper grade on the QBs. There are still several QBs that have the attributes to be a first round grade, including Arch Manning. He might not have had the season so far that everyone hoped he would, but he is still playing at a first round grade level. Others are rated higher yet, so I don't think there is going to a huge shortage of prospects come draft day.

Right now, I am still on CJ Carr as my top. I also still have Dante Moore right up there based on his skill set. Oregon has gone through some changes and I do think that is part of his decline.

I can't stop thinking about Mensah. He was on the one's to watch list and he is performing above anyone's expectations. If it stays status quo through the second half of the season, he is most likely your #1 QB prospect and probably the #1 overall draft pick of 2027. Mensah has been a high level QB, just at lower level schools until he transferred to Miami. Now it's on the biggest stage and he is lights out.

As of today, I still have all of these QBs with a first round grade, I would challenge you to change my mind (For the record, I had a 3rd round grade on Sanders and he went in the 5th round. I don't just hand out first round grades):
Darian Mensah
CJ Carr
Dante Moore
Arch Manning
Drew Mestemaker

Second round grade;
LaNorris Sellers
Trinidad Chambliss

I would happily take any of the top 5 guys above and believe truly that we have upgraded over Desaun Watson, let alone Shedeur Sanders.

I would trade up into the top 3 for Mensah and Carr, I would trade into the top 10 for Moore or Manning, the top 15 for Mestemaker. So trade evaluations would have to come once the draft order is set.

Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Public service announcement since this thread turned to QBs...

Make it a priority to watch Miami vs Notre Dame this weekend at 7:30 pm.. It will showcase two probable top ten picks in QBs Mensah and Carr.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Public service announcement since this thread turned to QBs...

Make it a priority to watch Miami vs Notre Dame this weekend at 7:30 pm.. It will showcase two probable top ten picks in QBs Mensah and Carr.

Thanks!


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I saw Mensah make a throw to Toney in the end zone that was sick.

He has incredible touch and he is really accurate.

I am not a college expert. I watch some highlights and then when the season ends start doing deep dives.

But everytime I have watched Mensah this year. He has been exceptional.

Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I wonder about Manning.

I have only watched bits and pieces of him playing.

What I have seen was a guy with good tools but questionable decision making.

I really don't know if he will live up to the hype of his name?


Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Dawg Talker
Offline
Dawg Talker
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 1,072
Originally Posted by bonefish
I wonder about Manning.

I have only watched bits and pieces of him playing.

What I have seen was a guy with good tools but questionable decision making.

I really don't know if he will live up to the hype of his name?



Got to throw out the lineage... There was only one Manning... er wait.. there were only two Mannings... no, no, wait.. there were only THREE Mannings.

Seriously though. If any person that actually shows talent on film should have a leg up on "help", he's the guy. I don't know how much his uncles or grand father have offered.. maybe they are the reason he has climbed as high as he has already? But, they should be able to help him transition from college to pro, for at least all the environment questions that come into play. They will probably throw him back to his coaches on player questions, but the outside noise should be lessened with their help in that aspect.

The kid has way above average talent. I haven't seen the ability to take all levels of talent around him and elevate it into a non-stop force of willing a team to win under any circumstance. That's what Peyton had.. Eli did not. Eli had great teammates around him that made HIM better. Never saw the old man play, so I don't have any clue on him.

Expectations are at an all time high for him though, I don't think there was ever a chance at him meeting those. The kid is playing at a high level and reporters are calling for the back up QB? What has he done to warrant that?

I would be happy to get a QB in the draft with his skill set.

Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Archie Manning the grandfather was really good.

A truly great player stuck on a bad team in New Orleans. Arch resembles him.

He was a multi-sport star in football, basketball, track, and baseball. He was drafted four times by Major League Baseball franchises but chose to pursue football.

He was 6'3" and was very athletic. He took a beating with New Orleans. They were terrible when he was there.

Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I have no idea what he is going to do.

He may transfer. He could have come out this past year. When that discussion was happening he said he is calling his own shots.

But who the hell knows I mean he is a Manning.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by bonefish
I have no idea what he is going to do.

He may transfer. He could have come out this past year. When that discussion was happening he said he is calling his own shots.

But who the hell knows I mean he is a Manning.

You never know. I have felt all along there was a good chance he wouldn't even enter this years draft. His family has money, he makes a ton of NIL money. There is also a history of the family staying in school. It's not like he is living in the crappy dorm room, living off the school meal ticket. It's not like he has family pressure to exit for the NFL.

He can sit back, see where he is projected to be drafted and see what teams would be likely to draft him. If he doesn't like the projected landing spot, it makes his decision to stay easier.

For the last 2 years, this included, he makes anywhere between $3 and $6 million a year. It just depends on the source and knowing what is verified and what other is projected. Given all the other reasons I cited, he doesn't even have to play in the NFL to have one heck of a head start on life.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Money obviously is not a factor.

Arch Manning is 22 years old. He was born on April 27th. He should be old enough to do what he feels is right.

Most of the time the first two quarterbacks selected go high in the draft. That is not a good thing. They go to the worst teams.

Arch Manning would be better off going later in round one to a team that has good young talent on the OL and skill positions.

You don't get to pick the team you would like to go to. But if he went to a team in the middle of the first he might have better success if that team has the patience to develop quarterbacks.

I have no idea if he will develop and become a good QB. There are a number of guys who look intriguing. But it is really hard to forecast success in the NFL at the QB position.

Aaron Rodgers is a HOF quarterback. He has a great arm. But you never see him gun the ball. He throws a catchable ball mostly with touch and timing.

Steve Smith the receiver has said numerous times "throw a catchable ball." Passes don't need to be smoked.

The game today appears to be more underneath and mid field than deep long shots.

Average Depth of Target (aDOT): Over recent seasons, the league-wide aDOT has dropped, hovering around 7.8 to 8.0 yards. In contrast, historical averages and peak passing eras saw average intended air yards consistently above 8.5 to 9.0+ yards. Breakdown of Throw Depths: NFL tracking data reveals how heavily skewed play-calling has become toward short and underneath passes:Short & Underneath (0–9 yards): ~49% of all passes Behind the Line (Screen/Swings): ~17.5% of all passes Intermediate (10–19 yards): ~21.5% of all passes Deep Passes (20+ yards): ~11.7% of all passes

The quarterback position is more about reading the field being accurate and on time.

The one guy who I have seen in college who fits that mold is Mensah. But I have not seen many of the prospects this year.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
H
Hall of Famer
Offline
Hall of Famer
H
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 6,128
The way this QB class is right now maybe one of them will fall to between the 10-15th slot where we could be picking and we won't have to use any draft capitol to move up. It's all speculation right now. Obviously, no one knows where we'll be picking and we have to like the guy but it's food for thought. The Rams did it with Simpson last year and they might have the replacement for Stafford already on the roster.

Last edited by Homewood Dog; 11/03/26 10:33 AM.
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
Originally Posted by bonefish

You don't get to pick the team you would like to go to.

That's not entirely true, particularly since we are talking about a Manning.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
There is a precedent there. I wouldn't go as far as to say you can pick the team you want to go to. But it certainly goes to show that in the case of the Manning family you don't have to play for the team that does draft you should you choose not to.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
I don't follow college football closely.

Before the season began Moore and Manning were considered the top two guys.

Hell maybe they still are even with Moore out and Manning's production questionable.

The others Sayin, Carr, Mensah, Mestemaker, Sellers who knows how they are viewed by teams.

They will be dissected when the season ends.

I have seen a little of Manning and some of Mensah.

The only thing I feel pretty certain of is if Manning is there when we pick. Haslam will draft him.

Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
I want Sellers in the middle of the 1st. He's doing everything he can to blow that though as he has been getting better by the week against stiff competition.

He has all the tools and a Josh Allen frame. He's 6'3" / 240 and was clocked at 20.8 mph this season. He can throw the ball 65+ yards without setting his feet.

He plays too much hero ball and rarely shows touch on his passes. He also has a hard time moving through progressions. Please keep doing all those things, LaNorris, until Berry turns in the card.


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
There is a precedent there. I wouldn't go as far as to say you can pick the team you want to go to. But it certainly goes to show that in the case of the Manning family you don't have to play for the team that does draft you should you choose not to.

No doubt, and NIL could make it even more prevalent. Bo Jackson was drafted by Tampa Bay and he refused to sign with Tampa because they did him dirty and made him ineligible for his final baseball season at Auburn. Other guys may not have baseball as a fall back, but having several $million already in the bank could easily sway someone from not even playing football, at least long enough to hold out from playing until the team that drafted him would trade the rights, and nobody would make the trade unless they were certain he was going to sign with them.

I think NIL will change more than just the NCAA.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
It certainly must have a huge influence. I mean before these athletes were risking a career ending injury and getting no financial gain from taking that risk. That's why I never understood the fans who judged them so harshly over leaving early for the NFL. Now at least the ones at the top are making some pretty good money staying in school.

I think as with most things there's a yin and a yang to it. It helps athletes decide to stay in school longer but also creates their freedom of movement. A really good athlete can make more in endorsement deals by going to a top rated school. I mean there are a few exceptions to that but as a general rule.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 9,835
Hall of Famer
Offline
Hall of Famer
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 9,835
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
So, I have some fundamental flaws with the plan.

1) I don't think Sanders is a 4500 yard per year QB. It doesn't matter the number of sockets you have in the set if the wrench is broken. Until the Browns build an offensive line capable of 150 yards rushing per game. Teams will find ways to neutralize the receivers without competence at QB. It takes a live arm to utilize guys like Smith, Boston and Concepcion.

2) Green isn't "that" guy. He is built more to make things happen, a poor man's Lamar. If you want the guy who will help get you to the 150 yards rushing per game, you aren't going to need an over load of WRs.

3) If neither 1. or 2. above are your answer at QB, giving up (3) first rounders for one guy that doesn't have the one tool he needs in place to succeed isn't just wasting his career, it's wasting the other two POSITIONS that you might have filled with the extra guys you gave up. I think we can all agree we are going to need help in the very near future at CB, EDGE and O-Line. We can keep filling those holes with 3rd rounders... but then we will continue talking about what are we going to do to upgrade the position.

QBs are not a dime a dozen, it is the most important position on a football team and it isn't close. Spending capital on someone you are convinced could fix the position for the next 15 years is a plan worth executing. Spending (3) firsts in a WR, where there are examples of really good players, and they actually become available in free agency on a regular basis as well, in my humble opinion is not.

Now, if the Rams pick ends up in the top (3) and two QBs go 1-2 and he is sitting there. THEN it depends on that QB we've all been discussing... Is one of the first two taken your guy, or is he still sitting there. If he's there, take him. If he is gone, I would LOVE to have Smith in a Browns uniform in the hopes that you can make magic happen with other picks in either this or the next draft to get an upgrade at QB... not in the 5th round mind you, someone WORTHY of a high draft pick.

I just want to thank you for your detailed response even if I don't agree with everything. I just love to see good arguments.

1)I don't think Sanders is a 4500 yard per year QB either. Then again neither is Burrows. Could we get a reliable 3500 yards if we draft Smith though? Yes, and very easily so. Sanders has the ability to throw the ball well. He just has to speed up his decision making and at the end of last year he was starting to show that it was possible.

2)I agree that Green is a poor man's Lamar. The thing is, Lamar was not so great either until Monken taught him how to be a better passer. Sadly Lamar doesn't seem to be able to stay healthy. I see Green as more of a Kordell Stewart role myself and think he would be great for that. Sanders as the starter and Green as his back up. I would love to see Green become the holder for the field goal kicker. A fake field goal where he takes off is scary with his speed.

3) Tell me what Elite QB we are going to draft in the next two years when we are making the playoffs? We won't be. Maybe LA's pick turns into gold but I doubt they keep losing once Myles recovers from his surgery as it was only a knee scope to clean up his knee. So in reality we are not drafting a great QB anytime soon. We just aren't. Any good ones if there are any will be taken long before we can pick him up and teams seldom trade down from picking a QB.

QBs are not even a nickel a dozen anymore. All I see in the last several years are a bunch of bleh. None of them seem that exciting to me. Are there any you like that you think are worth passing on the best WR to come out in at least a decade like Smith? I just don't see anyone worth passing him up or believe we would have the draft capital to land said QB. Hell, I am not even sure if Smith doesn't become the number 1 overall pick and becomes impossible for us to trade up and get. I just want Smith because I think he would elevate our offense to an elite level even with Sanders throwing him the ball or God forbid ... Watson throwing him the ball.

1) My problem with taking Smith after a giant trade up package is that if we did so he would probably immediately blow out his knee, get addicted to oxy, and drive the wrong way down a highway directly into a semi after finding out he also had stage IV prostate cancer. It's just how those moves work out for the Browns. More seriously, we've already heavily invested in the position. From a roster management perspective, pushing the investment to almost 5 first round picks at the position in 2 years doesn't really make sense.

2) The revisionist history on Lamar is wild. He won league MVP (unanimously, if I'm reading profootballreference right link) in his first full year as the starter with Greg Roman as his OC.

3) Lamar lasted to the end of the first round. Figuring out who the elite QBs are isn't an exact science, yet they still tend to generally go somewhere in round one if they may have a chance. Practically eliminating the possibility of having a chance at an elite rookie QB for the next two years seems misguided. Especially when it seems to be to over-invest at a position we just heavily invested in and those investments look to have been good ones.

Personally, I'm more looking at pass rushers and OTs. Also kind of wondering how far Mensah and Chambliss might last. They don't have the measurables to go Gaga over, but they can play the position. I'm probably not trading up for either, but if they are sitting there for us, I'm considering them strongly.

That's not to say he isn't a great player, but we have much bigger needs, and I'm not trading up for "luxury" tempting as it may be.


[Linked Image from i.ibb.co]
You mess with the "Bull," you get the horns.
Fiercely Independent.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Revisionist theory as we watch Tyler Shough with the Saints.

We could have drafted him instead of Judkins. If so no Gabriel or Sanders.

I thought he would have been a good pick in the second round.

There is no way that I would trade up for Smith unless we had a franchise QB in place.

Square one get your quarterback.

Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
No doubt it creates upheaval in the college ranks. I was just looking at it from how it can impact the NFL.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by bonefish
Revisionist theory as we watch Tyler Shough with the Saints.

We could have drafted him instead of Judkins. If so no Gabriel or Sanders.

I thought he would have been a good pick in the second round.

There is no way that I would trade up for Smith unless we had a franchise QB in place.

Square one get your quarterback.

We can say that in several cases. I would have taken Simpson.


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
Originally Posted by bonefish
Revisionist theory as we watch Tyler Shough with the Saints.

We could have drafted him instead of Judkins. If so no Gabriel or Sanders.

I thought he would have been a good pick in the second round.

There is no way that I would trade up for Smith unless we had a franchise QB in place.

Square one get your quarterback.

Not really the point of your post, but I still think we would've ended up drafting Sanders. Using a fifth was a no-brainer.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
B
Legend
Offline
Legend
B
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 40,810
Originally Posted by oobernoober
Originally Posted by bonefish
Revisionist theory as we watch Tyler Shough with the Saints.

We could have drafted him instead of Judkins. If so no Gabriel or Sanders.

I thought he would have been a good pick in the second round.

There is no way that I would trade up for Smith unless we had a franchise QB in place.

Square one get your quarterback.

Not really the point of your post, but I still think we would've ended up drafting Sanders. Using a fifth was a no-brainer.

You are right. It did exibit a lack of brains. thumbsup


If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.

GM Strong




[Linked Image]
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Originally Posted by oobernoober
Originally Posted by bonefish
Revisionist theory as we watch Tyler Shough with the Saints.

We could have drafted him instead of Judkins. If so no Gabriel or Sanders.

I thought he would have been a good pick in the second round.

There is no way that I would trade up for Smith unless we had a franchise QB in place.

Square one get your quarterback.

Not really the point of your post, but I still think we would've ended up drafting Sanders. Using a fifth was a no-brainer.

Disagree. We heard the same thing about a baker's dozen (pun intended) Browns QBs

Colt McCoy: "first-round talent"
DeShone Kizer: "all the tools"
Spergon Wynn, Charlie Frye, the list goes on.

These were all called great picks because of where they were drafted when not a soul had even an outside chance at fQB.

If you're going to treat QBs like stocks, you better already have one clear winner before you start trading on upside; because you can only have three in your portfolio.

And that three is a crowd when they all three think they are better than the other two and they should be starting. They use losing as evidence, become disgruntled and disenfranchised, and the whole room turns to shizzle.


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by bonefish
For the last two years Arch Manning was considered to be the crown jewel.

Royal blood a descendant of greatness.

Well the shine has come off. Where is Arch Manning as a prospect? Is the problem the head coach? Is the offensive system holding him back?

He was presumed to be the first pick in the draft. Well that boat has sailed.

Is there a silver lining?

He might be there when the Browns pick. There is no world that exists where Jimmy Haslam would not draft Manning. Jimmy could not help himself.

What I have seen of Manning is limited. I have not studied him. I have watched him for a few quarters. He showed ability and he made bad decisions.

We will not know the draft order till the season ends. Between the Rams pick and our pick maybe we are near the middle of the first round.

He could be there. That would be mind numbing.

Manning has the tools to be a very good QB but the offense on his team just sucks. They can't block and the wrs are pretty bad. I think he needs another year of college but that team has such lousy coaching I don't think he will gain anything from staying in college. He should just go pro and suffer in the pros. He will probably not be ready for the NFL for about 2 years. At least him and Green would be a wicked combo.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by FATE
I want Sellers in the middle of the 1st. He's doing everything he can to blow that though as he has been getting better by the week against stiff competition.

He has all the tools and a Josh Allen frame. He's 6'3" / 240 and was clocked at 20.8 mph this season. He can throw the ball 65+ yards without setting his feet.

He plays too much hero ball and rarely shows touch on his passes. He also has a hard time moving through progressions. Please keep doing all those things, LaNorris, until Berry turns in the card.

He just looks like another Jamarcus Russell to me. Hero ball and doesn't read the defense well enough presnap to make fast decisions. I'm just not impressed by him.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by FATE
I want Sellers in the middle of the 1st. He's doing everything he can to blow that though as he has been getting better by the week against stiff competition.

He has all the tools and a Josh Allen frame. He's 6'3" / 240 and was clocked at 20.8 mph this season. He can throw the ball 65+ yards without setting his feet.

He plays too much hero ball and rarely shows touch on his passes. He also has a hard time moving through progressions. Please keep doing all those things, LaNorris, until Berry turns in the card.

He just looks like another Jamarcus Russell to me. Hero ball and doesn't read the defense well enough presnap to make fast decisions. I'm just not impressed by him.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by IrishDawg42
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
And one big reason the Bears feel they are possibly just a player away is because they already have their QB. You can never get to that point until you do.

So who is your bonafine you want to draft Pit? I don't see one. All I see are a bunch of mediocre garbage. I don't see any elite QBs that scream we have to have this guy. Honestly, I find it hard to watch college football these days because the level of play just seems putrid anymore. The portal is flat our ruining college football to where only rich college programs are going to be able to keep any talent and smaller teams will just get striped bare. They will stop developing players because they have to win now while they have them for a year. QBs take the most time and effort to build up and why would any team bother when the second they get good they will just bail to a team that can pay them?

So I get that you WANT one. IS there one to be had especially where we will be drafting at?
Originally Posted by PitDAWG
As I explained, there are several that are far better options than anything we will be left with on the roster after watson leaves. Even you know that. Making the claim that trying to develop a 5th and a 7th round QB while dumping three first rounders on WR is some great option is off the chains crazy.


I'm with Pit on this one..

For one, there is no arguing who you want as a replacement in November before the season is even over. Too many things have to happen between now and the draft. 1) need to know the draft order 2) evaluate which teams will be in the market for a QB, to see where the possible trade spots are 3) Need to know the list of draft committed candidates.... THEN you can start evaluating draft grades on the prospects.

To Pit's point, you are talking about replacing a 5th round pick with a possible first round grade guy... What is your train of thought here? I agree, you don't give a 3rd round grade on a guy and reach for him in the first round, but regardless of where you are in the process and wanting Smith so badly that you don't give a proper grade on the QBs. There are still several QBs that have the attributes to be a first round grade, including Arch Manning. He might not have had the season so far that everyone hoped he would, but he is still playing at a first round grade level. Others are rated higher yet, so I don't think there is going to a huge shortage of prospects come draft day.

Right now, I am still on CJ Carr as my top. I also still have Dante Moore right up there based on his skill set. Oregon has gone through some changes and I do think that is part of his decline.

I can't stop thinking about Mensah. He was on the one's to watch list and he is performing above anyone's expectations. If it stays status quo through the second half of the season, he is most likely your #1 QB prospect and probably the #1 overall draft pick of 2027. Mensah has been a high level QB, just at lower level schools until he transferred to Miami. Now it's on the biggest stage and he is lights out.

As of today, I still have all of these QBs with a first round grade, I would challenge you to change my mind (For the record, I had a 3rd round grade on Sanders and he went in the 5th round. I don't just hand out first round grades):
Darian Mensah
CJ Carr
Dante Moore
Arch Manning
Drew Mestemaker

Second round grade;
LaNorris Sellers
Trinidad Chambliss

I would happily take any of the top 5 guys above and believe truly that we have upgraded over Desaun Watson, let alone Shedeur Sanders.

I would trade up into the top 3 for Mensah and Carr, I would trade into the top 10 for Moore or Manning, the top 15 for Mestemaker. So trade evaluations would have to come once the draft order is set.

Nice post with some good Answers. I'll have to watch some more footage on those guys before I make up my mind. I've been watching Manning and while I don't think he is ready for the nfl I would take him in the top 15 if he is not going to be rushed into starting. He would have way better weapons with the Browns than his current team but he makes some really boneheaded throws while under pressure which for him is always.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by bonefish
I don't follow college football closely.

Before the season began Moore and Manning were considered the top two guys.

Hell maybe they still are even with Moore out and Manning's production questionable.

The others Sayin, Carr, Mensah, Mestemaker, Sellers who knows how they are viewed by teams.

They will be dissected when the season ends.

I have seen a little of Manning and some of Mensah.

The only thing I feel pretty certain of is if Manning is there when we pick. Haslam will draft him.

I'm not that impressed by Mensah. He is bailed out by some great talent at WR who often get wide open. His throws don't have a lot of velocity in them which is going to hurt bad at the nfl level. To me his is an avg QB.


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
From what I have seen Mensah throws on time and accurately.

Carr looks kind of like Purdy to me smart and accurate.

I watched Levitt for the first time. I like him. He has turned it over too much but I like the way he plays.

I have not yet seen Mestemaker.

Seems like there will be some good options to choose from.

The way DW played against the Texans could change how the Browns approach the draft.

We are a 6-4 team with a realistic chance to make the playoffs.

Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
R
Hall of Famer
OP Offline
Hall of Famer
R
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 5,222
Originally Posted by bonefish
From what I have seen Mensah throws on time and accurately.

Carr looks kind of like Purdy to me smart and accurate.

I watched Levitt for the first time. I like him. He has turned it over too much but I like the way he plays.

I have not yet seen Mestemaker.

Seems like there will be some good options to choose from.

The way DW played against the Texans could change how the Browns approach the draft.

We are a 6-4 team with a realistic chance to make the playoffs.

Yeah, Mensah is accurate at the college level. So was Sanders. Accuracy is important no doubt. But without ball velocity those same passes against nfl level DBs get blocked or intercepted. I think any QB with poor ball velicity is going to have a rough time in the NFL. Julian is another accurate passer who relies on an elite WR to fight for the ball because his passes are accurate but too slow.

I mean you can tell when you are watching a good QB throw the ball because that ball will zing through the air. Honestly, I like our own Taylon Green better than most the QBs coming out in this draft. Green I think is who Monken is planning for the long term starter for the Browns. I don't care what round he was drafted. He is faster than Lamar. He has a strong arm even if his throwing mechanics need work ... Monken is the one who made Lamar learn to be a real passer so I think Monken can greatly improve Green into a real QB. Seriously. Watch some games Taylon Green plays and you will be shocked how good he can play. His only real problem is that he trusts his strong arm too much and will force throws. Yet he will make fast decisions and get the ball gone or get himself gone. I would love it if he would play HB for us.

Imagine Arch at QB while Green is taking handoffs from him and either of them can run for a TD or just pass it. That would be some fine football to watch. Both Arch and Green can throw the ball all the way down the field through the air. Then could pass the ball to each other and teams would have a nightmare stopping that combination


You can't fix stupid but you can destroy ignorance. When you destroy ignorance you remove the justifications for evil. If you want to destroy evil then educate our people. Hate is a tool of the stupid to deal with what they can't understand.
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 18,149
The NFL changes because they adapt to trends.

The deep ball is rare anymore. The game is becoming more about getting the ball out to short and inter-mediate routes.

NFL defenses looking to eliminate the deep ball rely on two-high safety shells (such as Cover 2, Cover 4/Quarters, and Cover 6) combined with a disciplined four-man pass rush.


Drew Brees and Phillip Rivers never had had high velocity arms. It was about anticipation, timing and accuracy.

Brock Purdy is an example. He reads it and gets it out.

I like Mensah and think he will do well. Sanders main issue was taking sacks and going backwards in the pocket. He was accurate but he depended upon seeing open and not anticipating open.

Mensah does not play that way. His last game with Toney out. He still was successful.

Guys who can read it and get the ball with timing and accuracy have the edge.

Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
... Monken is the one who made Lamar learn to be a real passer so I think Monken can greatly improve Green into a real QB.

I'm being nitpicky, but Lamar was drafted in 2018, and Monken joined the Ravens in 2023. Lamar had 2 QB coaches (James Urban from 2018 until 2022, and Tee Martin after that).

More to your point, I am more confident in Monken and Company's ability to coach up a QB than I think I have been in any Browns coaching staff of recent memory simply due to what we're seeing from Watson this year.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
Folks on here have said this before, but arm strength/velocity is important so long as you have it to a certain point. Having a noodle-arm is bad, having NFL-adequate arm strength is good, having a howitzer attached to your shoulder is better, but not by much. After a certain point, additional arm strength matters less and less.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
P
Legend
Offline
Legend
P
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 81,118
Not only that, Lamar's talent level caused him to be drafted at the end of round 1 while Green sat on the board until round 7. There are reasons why that happened. These apples to oranges comparisons seem rather crazy to me.


Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.

#gmstrong
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Legend
Offline
Legend
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 15,331
Originally Posted by oobernoober
Originally Posted by Razorthorns
... Monken is the one who made Lamar learn to be a real passer so I think Monken can greatly improve Green into a real QB.

I'm being nitpicky, but Lamar was drafted in 2018, and Monken joined the Ravens in 2023. Lamar had 2 QB coaches (James Urban from 2018 until 2022, and Tee Martin after that).

More to your point, I am more confident in Monken and Company's ability to coach up a QB than I think I have been in any Browns coaching staff of recent memory simply due to what we're seeing from Watson this year.

There is a lot more to "improving Green into a real QB" than just coaching him up. He throws with an elongated motion. It's almost as bad as Tebow. That doesn't change overnight and, in many cases, won't change at all.

He's thrown that way his whole life, so thinking you can change it and he can still be NFL worthy is a mostly wishful thinking... and definitely not something Monken is going to fix.

Eric Heiden is widely considered the greatest all-around speed skater of all time. He swept the '80 Olympics. A reporter, basically joking, asked if he could skate that fast going clockwise around the rink. A serious look crossed his face, he said if he tried to make a right turn at full speed he would fall on his face, every time. That's the kind of muscle memory we're working against here.


HERE WE GO BROWNIES! HERE WE GO!!
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
O
Legend
Offline
Legend
O
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 14,694
I understand... Green was available and taken where he was for a reason.

I was merely commenting on the work Monken has already done with a failed QB. I'm more comfortable drafting a non-top-5 QB and/or bringing in a reclaimation project QB than I would've been with past regimes.


"FIALURE IS NOT AN OPTION...!"

-mac
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
DawgTalkers.net Forums DawgTalk Tailgate Forum Jeremiah Smith Bandwagon

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5