DawgTalkers.net Forums DawgTalk Fantasy & Gaming Trade Advice....

Give up....T. Holt & M. Cassel

Acquire....R. Brown & B. Favre
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Would you make that trade ?.....

No way, Ronnie Brown is not the player he was last year, and its to early to tell how Cassel will do week-to-week. Favre and Brown are not worth it IMO.

Opinions ?....I already have Ricky Williams so Brown would give me the tandem....Favre would be an upgrade to Cassel....

I am more than happy to give my opinion when you give the information required!?

Redraft, Dynasty, Keeper, ppr, scoring, lineups, roster.

It is nigh on impossible to offer any trade advice with the information given so far?

Ok....Here 's the info 1 pt. per reception....1pt. per 10yds. for RB/WR/TE rushing....Distance TDs(6, 8,10)

1pt. per 20yds. for QBs....Distance TDs(3,4,5)....
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a Keeper League(but we can keep only 1 player so it's a Redraft League as well......** I already have Ricky Williams on my squad....

The only player of the 4 listed with any keeper value is Ronnie Brown. Having said that if you are only keeping 1 player per roster I am guessing you wouldn't be keeping Ronnie?

Holt is on what is one of the worst sides in the NFL, Cassell will do a job at QB. It seems a pretty even trade, but its difficult without knowing your roster? Is Holt currently starting for you? is Cassell? would Favre be an upgrade on what you have? would Brown be a starter on your team?

O f course I had T. Brady Yes , Yes , Yes.....Holt starts for me....Currently I have Cassell , Garcia and just added Collins....Favre IMO would be an upgrade : My Ball Handlers are Ricky Williams , L. Johnson , D.Williams , K. Smith WRS : Holt , S. Moss , B. Johnson , D. Mason ,(K. Robinson , D. Hester....)...Robinson & Hester will probably have to be upgraded at some point....

Ouch your side is hurting!

I would do the deal. Favre will be an upgrade and the bonus for length of TDs could be a nice little extra with Favre's link ups with Cotchery. I dont think you lose too much with Holt - his time as an elite FF WR is up I think!

I would also put LJ on the trade block - as the only real other 'stud name' I would see what you can get for him. Kansas are horrible.