If we're only considering numbers, I'd personally replace the vertical with the broad jump (or just add it). I think it displays explosion better, and since a pass rusher was specifically mentioned, explosion is vital. JMHO
There's some stat work done and I think it mostly says there's no statistical indicator of NFL success comparing 1 and 3+ year NFL starters to the AVG combine numbers.
That said, I've often found the forty to 3cone "gap" to be a decent indicator of success. At least many pass rush prospects that I know of that had a ~4.5 forty but ~4.4 3cone busted pretty hard.
All the rushers you posted have a significant forty-3cone gap of 0.4+....something to keep an eye on
#gmstrong
"Players come along at different points in time" - Ray Farmer