Do we have any more information on what actually happened?
Figured this would be widespread by now - I heard a report that the government had 2700 tonnes of ammonium nitrate had been seized and stored at that location for over 6 years... crazy I know. Nothing on how the blaze/explosion started, but that source of such a powerful explosion was that material. . . I was listening to the radio as reporters from the area were interviewed saying that all the glass in their neighborhoods had shattered, and they lived a mile from the location of the blast!!! Just wow.
Last edited by mgh888; 08/05/2009:11 AM.
The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
MOAB, our most powerful non nuke... This explosion was similar to one of these but seemed to be much bigger. The initial blast ring was more like the shockwave from a warhead.
Beirut blast site contained 2,700 tons of ammonium nitrate, and fireworks
In this drone picture, the destroyed silo sits in rubble and debris after an explosion at the seaport of Beirut, Lebanon, Lebanon, Wednesday, Aug. 5, 2020. The massive explosion rocked Beirut on Tuesday, flattening much of the city's port, damaging buildings across the capital and sending a giant mushroom cloud into the sky. (AP Photo/Hussein Malla)
Jon Gambrell And Josef Federman, The Associated Press Published Wednesday, August 5, 2020 6:18AM EDT
Fireworks and ammonium nitrate appear to have been the fuel that ignited a massive explosion that rocked the Lebanese capital of Beirut, experts and videos of the blast suggest.
The scale of the damage - from the epicenter of the explosion at the port of Beirut to the windows blown out kilometres (miles) away - resembles other blasts involving the chemical compound commonly used as an agricultural fertilizer.
But the compound itself typically doesn't detonate on its own and requires another ignition source. That likely came from a fire that engulfed what initially appeared to be fireworks that were stored at the port.
Online videos of the disaster's initial moments show sparks and lights inside the smoke rising from the blaze, just prior to the massive blast. That likely indicates that fireworks were involved, said Boaz Hayoun, owner of the Tamar Group, an Israeli firm that works closely with the Israeli government on safety and certification issues involving explosives.
“Before the big explosion, you can see in the centre of the fire, you can see sparks, you can hear sounds like popcorn and you can hear whistles,” Hayoun told The Associated Press. “This is very specific behaviour of fireworks, the visuals, the sounds and the transformation from a slow burn to a massive explosion.”
Jeffrey Lewis, a missile expert at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies in Monterey, California, offered a similar assessment.
“It looks like an accident,” Lewis told the AP. “First, there was a fire preceding the explosion, which is not an attack. And some of the videos show munitions what I could call popcorning, exploding like 'pop, pop, pop, pop.”'
He added that “it's very common to see fires detonate explosives.”
“If you have a fire raging next to something explosive, and you don't put it out, it blows up,” he said.
The white cloud that accompanied the massive blast appeared to be a condensation cloud, often common in massive explosions in humid conditions that can follow the shock waves of an explosion, Lewis said.
Orange clouds also followed the blast, likely from toxic nitrogen dioxide gas that's released after an explosion involving nitrates.
Experts typically determine the power of the blast by measuring the crater left behind, which appeared massive in aerial footage shot on Wednesday morning by the AP.
The Beirut blast, based on the crater and glass windows being blown out a distance away, exploded with the force equivalent to detonating at least 2.2 kilotons of TNT, said Sim Tack, an analyst and weapons expert at the Texas-based private intelligence firm Stratfor.
What initially started the fire at the port remains unclear. Beirut was sunny before Tuesday's explosion, with a daily high of 30 degrees Celsius (86 degrees Fahrenheit).
Lebanese Interior Minister Mohammed Fahmi, in comments to a local TV station, made no mention of ignited fireworks but said it appeared the blast was caused by the detonation of more than 2,700 tons of ammonium nitrate that had been stored in a warehouse at the dock ever since it was confiscated from a cargo ship in 2014. That amount could cause the explosive force seen in the blast Tuesday, Tack said.
Based on the timeline and the size of the cargo, that ship could be the MV Rhosus. The ship was initially seized in Beirut in 2013 when it entered the port due to technical problems, according to lawyers involved in the case. It came from the nation of Georgia, and had been bound for Mozambique.
“Owing to the risks associated with retaining the ammonium nitrate on board the vessel, the port authorities discharged the cargo onto the port's warehouses,” the lawyers wrote in a 2015 article published by shiparrested.com. “The vessel and cargo remain to date in port awaiting auctioning and/or proper disposal.”
It remains unclear what conditions the ammonium nitrate had been stored in - or why tons of an explosive chemical compound had been left there for years. Lebanon already was on the brink of collapse amid a severe economic crisis that has ignited mass protests in recent months.
The devastation surrounding the port resembled other ammonium nitrate explosions, such as the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing and a 1947 ship explosion that struck Texas City, Texas.
It also is unclear what conditions a possible shipment of fireworks at the port had been stored in. Fireworks are very common in Lebanon, used to celebrate religious occasions and weddings.
While military explosives are generally safe to transport, common “cheap pyrotechnics” made in China are often of very low quality and can ignite very easily, especially in hot weather, said Hayoun, the Israeli explosives expert.
The “end result,” he added is that “hundreds of tons of energetic materials” were detonated to create a explosion of this magnitude.
'40: Who is blaming Trump for the explosion? His calling it an attack is however, fanning the flames of international politics...
32...you nailed it..as soon as Trump hinted that the explosion was "an attack", Trump made the subject a political issue.
The Lebanese hear that the American President says that the explosion was "an attack" according to US Generals and that the explosion was likely caused by a "bomb of some kind"...
...could these comments by our American President be considered "political" by Lebanon or other countries in the middle east?...RWERS, YOU TELL ME !
...Supporters of the Lebanese, you think they might take our President's comments, that the explosion was the result of a bomb, in a "political way".
...how bout the supporters of Israel, think the comments from Trump might be taken as "political"?
There are times when it is in the best interest of the USA if our leaders stop creating "political problems" for other countries as well as our own country.
Do we have any more information on what actually happened?
Figured this would be widespread by now - I heard a report that the government had 2700 tonnes of ammonium nitrate had been seized and stored at that location for over 6 years... crazy I know. Nothing on how the blaze/explosion started, but that source of such a powerful explosion was that material. . . I was listening to the radio as reporters from the area were interviewed saying that all the glass in their neighborhoods had shattered, and they lived a mile from the location of the blast!!! Just wow.
I did a little math and conversion to TNT equivalence to give this blast some scale.
1 unit of ammonium nitrate equals 0.42 units of TNT That 2700 tons of AN is 1,134 tons of TNT
This was a 1.13 kiloton detonation. Hiroshima and Trinity were 20 kiloton detonations.
The largest non-nuclear warhead in the US arsenal is the MOAB, which was used in Afhganistan to collapse mountain caves/tunnels. It's yield is a pittance at just merely 11 tons.
Browns is the Browns
... there goes Joe Thomas, the best there ever was in this game.
Well, I’m actually glad this isn’t a terrorist attack, just a really horrible accident.
RIP to those who died, and hope they fix the damage in a reasonable timeframe to get people back into their homes.
“To announce that there must be no criticism of the President, or that we are to stand by the President, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public.”
Well I like hoping for the best, despite usual expectations. I rather it not be a terrorist attack.
“To announce that there must be no criticism of the President, or that we are to stand by the President, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public.”
Goes to show you shouldn't store that much nitrate in one place.
You need to split that crap all across town. A van full blew up a block in OKC. It shouldn't be stored anywhere near a populated area.
I don't mean to minimize the lives or 10-12 workers in some warehouse somewhere, but they know what they have. They get paid a wage they deem fair. The person down the street doesn't have a clue.
If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
Maybe Trump will tell us what great Generals he talked to who claimed this was an "attack" with a "bomb".
Esper contradicts Trump: 'Most believe' Beirut explosion was an accident BY ELLEN MITCHELL - 08/05/20 04:09 PM EDT
By The Associated Press Updated August 5, 2020 5:55 AM link
Defense Secretary Mark Esper on Wednesday said “most believe” the massive explosions that killed at least 100 people in Beirut was an accident, contradicting President Trump who a day prior had called the blasts an “attack.”
While the Trump administration is still getting information on what happened on Tuesday, “most believe it was an accident, as reported,” Esper said during the Aspen Security Forum.
Esper declined to give more information on the explosion that left widespread devastation throughout Lebanon's capital city, but called the situation a “tragedy.”
“Lebanon’s struggling right now in a number of ways and it’s just a shame to see it happen. When you see the video it’s just devastating,” he said.
Esper's remarks contradict those made by Trump Tuesday evening, when he said his military and national security advisors indicated to him the explosion was caused by "a bomb of some kind" and called it an “attack.”
The Lebanese government, meanwhile, has said the explosion was probably caused by highly explosive material that was in storage at the port after being confiscated from a ship. But officials there have not indicated whether the explosions were deliberate or an accident.
The blast sent shockwaves across the city that overturned cars, blew out windows, collapsed balconies and roofs and injured thousands of people.
he Pentagon chief said that he had spoken to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo earlier on Wednesday about offering humanitarian assistance to the country and that the administration had reached out to the Lebanese government.
“We’re positioning ourselves to provide them whatever assistance we can, humanitarian aid, medical supplies, you name it to assist the people of Lebanon.”
Lebanon is currently in the midst of a massive economic crisis in addition to the COVID-19 pandemic.
mac, it's upsetting that you see this as yet another avenue to bash the president of the United States instead of concentrating on the loss of human lives.
I have seen the same thing w/Covid 19. People using the loss of life as a political tool while people are dying.
Of course, if Hillary was our president, the right wingers would be blaming her for Covid-19 and trashing her for whatever comment she made about the tragedy in Beirut.
I think lack of character and ethics are at an all-time high in this country. It's very sad to see.
vers...so you didn't like the article I posted, titled "Esper contradicts Trump: 'Most believe' Beirut explosion was an accident BY ELLEN MITCHELL"
The first paragraph of the AP story reads...Defense Secretary Mark Esper on Wednesday said “most believe” the massive explosions that killed at least 100 people in Beirut was an accident, contradicting President Trump who a day prior had called the blasts an “attack.”
vers...your problem with the article needs to addressed to the AP.
The president is using those same dead people as a reason to float a conspiracy theory doesn't seem to bother you nearly as much as the people who point it out. Strange.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
The president is using those same dead people as a reason to float a conspiracy theory doesn't seem to bother you nearly as much as the people who point it out. Strange.
This is interesting. We had a previous president that would take months to declare an actual terror attack as a terror attack. I don't think he ever declared fort hood anything other than a "man caused disaster".
Now we have a president that says this event, "may have been an attack", and you guys want to sling mud. We still don't know what caused the conditions for this stuff to explode.
Quite honestly, I would put this as possibly a foreign government destroying a stockpile of bomb making ingredients.
This is interesting. We had a previous president that would take months to declare an actual terror attack as a terror attack.
Maybe because you can't always tell moments, days after such a incident.. Maybe it's because the previous president wasn't a MORON who only wants to stoke the flames of hate and fear.
Last edited by Damanshot; 08/08/2008:45 AM.
#GMSTRONG
“Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts.” Daniel Patrick Moynahan
"Alternative facts hurt us all. Think before you blindly believe." Damanshot
So Putin knew it was there. trump’s favorite dictator playing games with the world again no doubt. And there will be no response from the trump admin once again. Let’s not forget the bounty money on American soldiers heads Putin put up. But I know some will.
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants." Thomas Jefferson.
Fábrica de Explosivos Moçambique (FEM), a Mozambican explosives manufacturing company, told CNN that they were the ones who originally ordered the ammonium nitrate that was left at Beirut's port for nearly seven years. The order of ammonium nitrate was intended for manufacturing explosives for mining companies in Mozambique, the spokesperson said.
The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
This is interesting. We had a previous president that would take months to declare an actual terror attack as a terror attack.
Maybe because you can't always tell moments, days after such a incident.. Maybe it's because the previous president wasn't a MORON who only wants to stoke the flames of hate and fear.
That president you love so much wouldn't call a terror attack when the terrorists screamed allahu akbar before the attack. And in my opinion, "maybe an attack" really fails to fan any flames, because it may not be. It's definitely not as inflamitory as saying, "it was an attack" without evidence.
And Trump didn't call it a terrorist attack when eleven people died in the Pittsburgh synagogue attack, the worst anti-Semitic violence in recent US history.
I know that's obviously different to you.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Fábrica de Explosivos Moçambique (FEM), a Mozambican explosives manufacturing company, told CNN that they were the ones who originally ordered the ammonium nitrate that was left at Beirut's port for nearly seven years. The order of ammonium nitrate was intended for manufacturing explosives for mining companies in Mozambique, the spokesperson said.
Yeah, but, facts don't matter in his attempt to blame everything on trump.
Yeah, showing the perfect example of what he was talking about is so off base.
If you tried to hold Trump half as accountable for the things he says as you do me you would have a new career.
But you'll never do that. You've already made it a part time job rationalizing and ignoring what a president says because you're too busy deflecting and trying to blame everyone else for it.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Mmmmm hmmm. From someone who is too lazy to do their own homework that's pretty rich. You're always asking questions expecting someone else to find the answers to them. Unlike others who find sources, figures and facts to bring to the table.
Sorry arch, you failed the test.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.