Let's add Josh Allen to this list who was in the same draft class as Baker.
IMO, this is the real discussion, not Shadeur vs Watson. The current QB room has not shown itself to be capable of NFL winning caliber play. It's the Kobiashi Maru. I have zero confidence in any of the QBs when they step onto the field. They have no "it" factor; some of them show energy and mechanics, but I've not seen anyone who can step onto the field with a "let's go win this toughness." It's a circus of bad decisions and shortened drives. Imagine being an offensive player on the Browns who's contract is loaded with incentives and seeing whichever QB is pulling the trigger. They can't/won't say it, but they're not excited either.
How is it that the Browns have misfired on drafted QBs since 2015 (except Baker Mayfield)? Look at the list: Kessler, Kizer, Baker, DTR, Gabriel and Sanders. I'm still not sure that Sanders is getting a fair shake, or even if the Browns really want to develop him. Seems like another placeholder until the "next great QB" that Haslam has tunnel vision for.
I'm beginning to wonder if the Browns FO worst nightmare is that Sanders or Watson will play well enough to make the team look good, when a bad result is something they seem to have gone out of their way to orchestrate.
Just my two Lincolns...oh wait, they don't mint those anymore...
We are definitely looking at the draft to be the savior .. now we have to hope that Manning, Moore, Sellers, Carr, etc, whichever on we choose, pans out. If not, it's another huge set back
"First down inside the 10. A score here will put us in the Super Bowl. Boston is far to the left as KC settles into the slot. Fannin is flanked out wide to the right. Judkins and Sampson are split in the backfield as the ball is hiked ... Here we go."
I keep reading that the Colts want to trade Richardson, the Vikings want to trade McCarthy, the Titans want to trade Levis, but I do not read of the Browns having any interest in anyone. It seems as though the Browns are HAPPY with Sanders/Watson/Gabriel. Their Browns appear nowhere in any discussion. I understand the writers are writing to fill space, get clicks and sell ads, but I would take any, absolutely any of above QBs over Watson/Sanders/Gabriel. I would trade ALL 3 and a 3rd round pick for any of them. I have no confidence that ANY our current top 3 QBs would do anything but lead us to an NEW RECORD .. 0 - 17 SEASON. I realize the Browns want a the top draft pick in the 2027 Draft, but I have been a Browns fan since 1962 and would like to see 1 more NFL Championship ( now known as Super Bowl ) before I die. GET A FREAKING QB !!
OK .. Rant over ..
The Cleveland Browns - WE KNOW QUARTERBACKS ( Look at how many we've had ... )
I think we are resigned to the fact that we'll stink this year regardless of who is the QB from the above options. But I agree, I hate punting the season before week 1 even starts
"First down inside the 10. A score here will put us in the Super Bowl. Boston is far to the left as KC settles into the slot. Fannin is flanked out wide to the right. Judkins and Sampson are split in the backfield as the ball is hiked ... Here we go."
Old , old , old Browns Fan A Tic ; Just don't understand why the fans keep going to the stadium putting money in Haslam pocket.. They and the NFL deserve national embarrassment . Seems like we have this discussion every year ..
I keep reading that the Colts want to trade Richardson, the Vikings want to trade McCarthy, the Titans want to trade Levis, but I do not read of the Browns having any interest in anyone. It seems as though the Browns are HAPPY with Sanders/Watson/Gabriel. Their Browns appear nowhere in any discussion. I understand the writers are writing to fill space, get clicks and sell ads, but I would take any, absolutely any of above QBs over Watson/Sanders/Gabriel. I would trade ALL 3 and a 3rd round pick for any of them. I have no confidence that ANY our current top 3 QBs would do anything but lead us to an NEW RECORD .. 0 - 17 SEASON. I realize the Browns want a the top draft pick in the 2027 Draft, but I have been a Browns fan since 1962 and would like to see 1 more NFL Championship ( now known as Super Bowl ) before I die. GET A FREAKING QB !!
OK .. Rant over ..
Originally Posted by Frenchy
Sign Jimmy G, legit NFL QB still on the streets.
I honestly believe they want to lose as many games as possible, so maybe they can get a great pick. If not they woulda brought a proven guy in!
Is this really what it has come to? Getting rid of bad QBs and eating salary cap, to bring in more really bad QBs, just because ours are in font of us and the others currently aren't?
JJ McCarthy has been a bigger hot mess than SS. Richardson hasn't shown anything to date. Will Levis, we're talking about Will Levis?
Finally, Jimmy G is only legit when it comes to talking about being a legitimately bad QB.
They didn't do anything this year because there was NO options to do anything this year. It is what it is. Frankly, I think we win the same number of games plugging in any of the 4 QBs. They will win some games, but might not beat last year's number.
The better those top QB's look the better for us. I hope they all look really good because if they do one will be a Brown next April.
The thing I am hanging my hat on is the Browns over the past two off seasons has put a future prospect into a much better situation than any of our past QBs. Personally, I think Boston is a future star in this league. I think he is the type of player that makes a QB shine. I really am on the bandwagon of this group of QBs. I am notoriously hard on QBs. I am adamantly against taking a QB just because we need one.. however, this year, I am extremely excited that the player will justify the position of the draft to take him. Unless, 3/4 of them decide to stay in school, we will have at least a couple to choose from that I will be excited about. The first one taken is not necessarily going to be the most successful. If the organization isn't set up for success, that player will fail. In the past that was us, I mostly excited because I don't feel that is still the case... it's also the reason why we could surprise and win 6 games or so. Regardless, if we are close to the top ten, we should have enough ammunition to get one of the top prospects.
As of today, I am keeping a very close eye on those top 4 guys. If the draft was taking place today, I would rank them at Moore, Carr, Sayin and Manning. I'm sure Haslem has a very different ranking...
Irish, I'd keep two lists going. As you stated, a list of the top 4, but I'd keep a list of QBs outside the top 4.
I'm assuming the Browns win 7-9 games. The Browns may not be able to draft one of the top guys.
My gut says Berry wants LaNorris Sellers.
If you recall, both Jackson and Mahomes had question marks about their ability to transition to the NFL. Thus, neither was drafted first.
That is not to say Sellers is as talented as these two guys. Sellers has some unique talent that, with the right surroundings, could potentially be a great QB.
Irish, I'd keep two lists going. As you stated, a list of the top 4, but I'd keep a list of QBs outside the top 4.
I'm assuming the Browns win 7-9 games. The Browns may not be able to draft one of the top guys.
My gut says Berry wants LaNorris Sellers.
If you recall, both Jackson and Mahomes had question marks about their ability to transition to the NFL. Thus, neither was drafted first.
That is not to say Sellers is as talented as these two guys. Sellers has some unique talent that, with the right surroundings, could potentially be a great QB.
I'll be watching Sellers pretty closely to see how he responds after a rough season. Hopefully he bounces back.
You mess with the "Bull," you get the horns. Fiercely Independent.
Irish, I'd keep two lists going. As you stated, a list of the top 4, but I'd keep a list of QBs outside the top 4.
I'm assuming the Browns win 7-9 games. The Browns may not be able to draft one of the top guys.
My gut says Berry wants LaNorris Sellers.
If you recall, both Jackson and Mahomes had question marks about their ability to transition to the NFL. Thus, neither was drafted first.
That is not to say Sellers is as talented as these two guys. Sellers has some unique talent that, with the right surroundings, could potentially be a great QB.
I'll be watching Sellers pretty closely to see how he responds after a rough season. Hopefully he bounces back.
Me too. Probably my favorite QB likely to see the '27 draft.
Kind of like our preseason game, I'm not sure how much is about the QB, versus how much is about the competition. Stanford might not be very good this year. I'm seeing 3.5 projected wins. (Edit: per sports-reference, Stanford literally had the worst pass defense in all of FBS last season.)
Still Mensah and Toney did look good. We'll see if they can keep it going as the season heats up. I'll take as many good looking potential QB options as possible, please.
Last edited by Bull_Dawg; 09/05/2608:44 AM.
You mess with the "Bull," you get the horns. Fiercely Independent.
Irish, I'd keep two lists going. As you stated, a list of the top 4, but I'd keep a list of QBs outside the top 4.
I'm assuming the Browns win 7-9 games. The Browns may not be able to draft one of the top guys.
My gut says Berry wants LaNorris Sellers.
If you recall, both Jackson and Mahomes had question marks about their ability to transition to the NFL. Thus, neither was drafted first.
That is not to say Sellers is as talented as these two guys. Sellers has some unique talent that, with the right surroundings, could potentially be a great QB.
I'll be watching Sellers pretty closely to see how he responds after a rough season. Hopefully he bounces back.
Me too. Probably my favorite QB likely to see the '27 draft.
I just watched a highlight video of him, very impressive.
Excel sheet online. I can't figure out how to post tables in this format.
Lanorris Sellers played Kent State but they pulled him early in the 2nd half because it was such a blowout, he ended with 270 passing, 3 TDs, No INTs, 1 rush yard. AI admitted he should have been on the list.. weird.
CJ Carr and Trinidad Chambliss are playing right now.
IF you are able to see the list, you can make note that none of them played a decent team.
CJ Carr is playing Wisconsin this week, it might be the best match up of the QBs for this week. It could be argued that Boise State has been competitive the past several seasons, so Dante Moore might have a good matchup as well.
If it had been Clemson, I think the odds of him landing here would be better. It was Tennessee, where Haslam is a big donor, that he had his ugly exit. Haslam should have pretty good intel anyways.
Iamaleava is interesting on the field for sure.
You mess with the "Bull," you get the horns. Fiercely Independent.
None of the top QB's played anyone of note this past week-end so I'm not sure how much we can take away from any of that. But if we're speaking strictly about QB performances Julian Sayin had a great game as well......
Completions/Attempts: 21–25, Completion Percentage: 84.0%, Passing Yards: 320, Touchdowns: 3, Interceptions: 0, Passer Rating: 231.1. He was pulled from the game early in the third quarter
It's yet to be determined if he will be coming out in next years draft and this is only his second season as starting QB. Which to me makes his stats last season even more surprising........
College football is different from the NFL in so many ways. Conferences and competition are all over the place. Josh Allen played for Wyoming. Good players are going to play uneven competition.
I watched part of the Miami versus Stanford game. I don't know the Stanford team.
I was watching Mensah. I was watching how he played. Not their offense so much or Stanford's defense.
I was looking at how he set-up. How his feet worked. How he positioned himself to throw. Where he throw from. His release. His hip rotation and follow through. On the pass was it his first read? If not where did his eyes go. Was the ball on time and where was the ball placement.
I look for throws that will look the type of throws that are made in the NFL.
I don't care about TDs to wide open guys or, easy throws. Can he throw on time, accurate throws, into tight windows?
Sometimes the 400 yard 4 TD games don't show much. Sometimes the 160 yard games do.
I watched some of Norte Dame game. I hated their offense. I dislike 100% shot gun. The handoffs and run game are horrible.
I am trying to see if the skills a guys shows are the transferable. I don't have the college football knowledge to know how good each corner is.
Mensah was impressive. He looked the part. Hell when the draft comes it is crapshoot anyway. I just try to find guys I like knowing I could be dead wrong.
I get what you're saying but often times teams that are mismatched do give QB's opportunities they do not get against better opponents. It's much easier for a QB to do the things you speak of when they are comfortable, not pressured and have more time in the pocket. When you're not being pressured your game will flow in your own comfort zone. Not saying that's the case here because I didn't watch the game.
If you play a much weaker team your WR's aren't facing top end defenders. It makes it much easier for your WR's to get open than they may be against much better opponents. Your OL isn't facing top tier DL and LB's which also makes their jobs easier to protect the QB.
Top CB's, DL, OL and every position on the field whose aspiration and talent makes their goal playing in the NFL go to schools where they get the most attention and the most exposure. Many of those who don't go to the top schools do so because they aren't sure they could win the starting position so it's easier for them to be starters and get more exposure at a smaller school than sitting on the bench at a better school.
It does make it easier to see what they can and will do when they're in their comfort zone. What their natural tendencies are when you have the luxury of playing against inferior players. It doesn't tell you what they will do when their teams talent has to face similar talent and they're thrown out of their comfort zones. How a QB will react or what he may revert to when his WR's don't get open on a regular basis and he has to throw into traffic more often. How his mechanics may change when regularly pressured. How he reacts when he has to lead his team on late, game winning drives. The judge of a great QB is how they react when the heat is on. You don't win it all in the NFL based on playing inferior teams.
And yes you can bring up Josh Allan. On rare occasions even QB's who play on lower tier teams can develop into more. It's just not a very common occurrence.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
I like both Mensah and Carr, however, neither has played a viable opponent yet. Carr played Wisconsin, but they looked second rate for a B1G school.
This week Miami gets Wake Forest on Friday, while not a powerhouse, they have played good football so far in 2026. Notre Dame gets Michigan State Saturday night. Again, Sparty won't be in line for a conference championship, but they are a good test. While most conferences are playing MAC schools and FCS level schools to warmup their season, Notre Dame is warming up with B1G schools...
I have to go with Irish by agreeing that neither of those two has faced a serious opponent. Two of the top ranked QB's have.
Sayin and Arch.
That second half by Manning gave a glimpse at what you need in an NFL QB. The ability to rally the troops and fight your way back to victory from the jaws of defeat.
As a big OSU homer if there was any way I could spin it to make Sayin look better than Arch in that game I certainly would. But that comeback was a thing of beauty.
As you stated there's a long way to go in this season. But for me the most critical part of this process is when they play against strong opponents. It's as close as we get to see to them playing at the next level. Against OSU, when the chips were down, Arch passed the test.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
There is no way I am going to follow all the players in college. Every team plays cupcakes and a few better teams.
Unless you know the corners who will make it into the NFL and see them against the qb?
I watch the quarterback. I look for plays where the coverage is tight. Can he throw with anticipation, timing, and accuracy? Can he layer throws with touch? Can he throw the deep out. Back shoulder? Do I see the types of throws that he would have to make in the NFL?
How does he handle pressure? Is he mobile? Can he escape and keep his eyes downfield?
I am looking for skills that transfer to the NFL game.
The percentage of college players who will make an NFL roster is under 2%. Higher for the big time schools but not much.
He will not face very many NFL type guys. So you try to see what you can.
Ohio State Buckeyes: 11 players selected (including 4 in the first round)
Texas A&M Aggies: 10 players selected
Alabama Crimson Tide: 10 players selected
Miami Hurricanes: 9 players selected
Clemson Tigers: 9 players selected
Oklahoma Sooners: 7 players selected
Iowa Hawkeyes: 7 players selected
Washington Huskies: 7 players selected
It's not as hard to figure out as you're making it sound.
Against lesser teams good teams face less QB pressures. Against lesser teams the secondary coverage isn't as good. Against lesser teams the talent on both sides of the ball is inferior to highly ranked teams.
The best players are recruited by the best schools. Unless an athlete believes he isn't good enough to win the starting job at those better schools, he will go to one of them. If playing in the NFL is their goal, winning a starting job at a top tier school gives them the national exposure they desire to make an NFL career more possible.
Who would go to an unranked school if they could be a starter at a nationally ranked school?
There's a reason athletes go to Ohio University or Kent State instead of Ohio State.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs - Texas Tech Lamar Jackson Baltimore Ravens - Louisville Josh Allen Buffalo Bills - Wyoming Joe Burrow Cincinnati Bengals - LSU Justin HerbertLos Angeles Chargers - Oregon C.J. Stroud Houston Texans - Ohio State Dak Prescott Dallas Cowboys - Mississippi State Jalen Hurts Philadelphia Eagles - Oklahoma Jared Goff Detroit Lions California - (Cal) Matthew Stafford Los Angeles Rams - Georgia Brock Purdy San Francisco 49ers - Iowa State Jordan Love Green Bay Packers - Utah State Baker Mayfield Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Oklahoma Trevor Lawrence Jacksonville Jaguars - Clemson Caleb Williams Chicago Bears - USC
No college quarterback faces NFL caliber "corners" every week.
Quarterbacks can come from any team if they have the talent.
I have no idea why you feel that way. I'm only basing my opinion on what I saw him do against Ohio State. A single game is not much to go on there. Unlike you I don't really have a juju meter. I suppose that's why I don't make a seven figure salary to sort all of that out. A good juju meter could go a long way at increasing my income. If your juju meter proves to be true I would suggest you strongly consider a career change. Andrew Berry makes an estimated $3.3 million to over $4 million per year.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
No they don't face NFL corners every week. Nor do they face NFL caliber players at any position every week. But when they do it's more meaningful than playing against nobodies.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Why do I feel like Arch Manning will just be the next chapter of the curse?
I can't explain it, but my juju meter says we want no part of it.
That's why I am scrutinizing this coaching staff to the fullest. IF they don't show they can lead a professional team onto the field, I want a full revamp to go with the shiny new QB. That will hopefully give the QB a full 5 years to grow with a competent staff.
Let's play the "what if" game. What if the Browns have two top 5 picks? What if Stafford continues to decline and the Rams defense continues to decline? What if McVay's contract extension has an out? What if the Browns could get McVay from the Rams in return for their first round pick we received for Garrett?
None of this is feasible of course, but I do want a competent coaching staff in place in 2027 to go along with the QB that is drafted. I don't want the new QB to be on his second HC and OC going into his second year of his rookie deal. Rip the band aid off at year end if Monken and company do not look a lot more competent than they did Sunday. Find the next plausible McVay if you can't get the man himself. That doesn't mean the next man down McVay's coaching staff list...
No they don't face NFL corners every week. Nor do they face NFL caliber players at any position every week. But when they do it's more meaningful than playing against nobodies.
Agreed!! They must step up against the best competition on their schedule.
I just see who are considered the top quarterback prospects.
Watch them play and see who I like.
I am looking at traits that could make them successful.
I remember watching Josh Allen's college tape. He looked like a guy with the lowest floor and highest ceiling. Low completion percentage and high ints.
But you had to be blind not to see his potential.
Jim Brown scored 106 rushing touchdowns. Josh Allen has 81 rushing touchdowns. He is tied at 20 for the most "rushing" touchdowns. More than Tony Dorsett and Earl Campbell and some of the best running backs in history.
What guys do in college has to be taken with a grain of salt.
We have to get this draft right. I want to get a guy I believe in. When down two scores in the 4th quarter. I want to believe my guy can win this game.
Andrew Berry please find a guy we all can believe in.
I see what you're getting at and won't totally dismiss it. But even Josh Allan faced teams like Nebraska, Oregon and Iowa. He also faced Boise St. who were ranked #13 at the time.
I think it seems logical for NFL scouts to more heavily weigh how a college QB plays against his better competition than they would his weaker opponents. Less pressure and looser coverage makes it much harder to see what a QB would do in more stressful situations when facing far more adversity.
Quote
When down two scores in the 4th quarter. I want to believe my guy can win this game.
That's what we're both looking for. I think where we differ is I don't think I'm going to find out the answer to that question without heavily basing it on if he can do that against his best competition.
When you're playing a nobody team, you aren't facing much pressure. The coverage isn't as good on your WR's. It's much easier to get in your comfort zone and not be forced out if it.
For me the only way you can tell how a QB will perform under duress is when he is no longer in his comfort zone.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
I don't know what to make of Mensah yet. The touch and accuracy look great throwing into huge windows. I'd like to see more of the ability to rifle it into tight windows accurately. He's great with the club he's been using, just still trying to see what other clubs he has in his bag. Malachi Toney is roasting people.
You mess with the "Bull," you get the horns. Fiercely Independent.
You called it when you stated Haslam got involved, BUT, BUT, how can ANY organization miss/ or ignor character defects like Manziel and Watson brought to a team- one was a drug addict and other a sex addict.....and we paid a huge price for giving them the keys to team. One, Watson, had proved himself at pro level----but got hurt/ lost lots of time due to sex problem.....BOTH were obtained when the "team culture" stated character was important. BS.
No college Qb is a guarantee. I like big, strong guys- J Allen is my current heart throb.....Mayfield is/was too small, he's been hurt, gotten paid, but is a second tier Qb. Manning has the blood lines, and won a big game, he is on the radar of Haslam and lots of other teams. If he has no character flaws, I think he's about the best we'd have drafted in 50 years.
"You've never lived till you've almost died, life has a flavor the protected will never know" A vet or cop
I realize just because a college QB is 6'5 and 230 LBS. doesn't mean he can play in the NFL, but I would like to see our next QB be at least 6'3 and 220-225. At least in this scenario we don't have to question the physical aspect. Of course, he needs to have the traits of an NFL QB.
I see what you're getting at and won't totally dismiss it. But even Josh Allan faced teams like Nebraska, Oregon and Iowa. He also faced Boise St. who were ranked #13 at the time.
I think it seems logical for NFL scouts to more heavily weigh how a college QB plays against his better competition than they would his weaker opponents. Less pressure and looser coverage makes it much harder to see what a QB would do in more stressful situations when facing far more adversity.
Quote
When down two scores in the 4th quarter. I want to believe my guy can win this game.
That's what we're both looking for. I think where we differ is I don't think I'm going to find out the answer to that question without heavily basing it on if he can do that against his best competition.
When you're playing a nobody team, you aren't facing much pressure. The coverage isn't as good on your WR's. It's much easier to get in your comfort zone and not be forced out if it.
For me the only way you can tell how a QB will perform under duress is when he is no longer in his comfort zone.
Perfect example is Bryce Underwood, he has the comeback… against lowly Western Michigan AND the big win against Oklahoma, yet he doesn’t look like a NFL QB.
CJ Carr looks the part on all levels, but he hasn’t been challenged yet.
Manning looks like the best prospect of the last 10 years… then he doesn’t … then he does again. Same with Moore.
You aren’t going to get the perfect example in college ball. There just isn’t enough consistent competition to KNOW you found the right one. This year though, we have several that have traits consistent with successful NFL QBs. There could be more than one come out of this draft to become really good starting players.
You aren’t going to get the perfect example in college ball. There just isn’t enough consistent competition to KNOW you found the right one.
If there were perfect examples and air tight methods to identify the best QB's in every draft there wouldn't be nearly as many first round QB busts. All you can do is look at how they preform under pressure and their skill set then try to decide how that will transfer in the NFL.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Just watched OS Sayin- he throws a nice ball BUT- as the commentators pointed out, he doesn't see the whole field AT ALL. He locks on to his first read and throws it.....one pass thrown to Smith/well covered- there was a guy running COMPLETELY free in middle of field and he never gave the guy a glance- and easy touchdown missed......I would NEVER draft him.....his mind isn't quick enough.......I ain't saying I'm quick, just he doesn't have field vision.
"You've never lived till you've almost died, life has a flavor the protected will never know" A vet or cop
Manning did the same thing in the OSU-Texas game, he didn't see wide open receivers numerous times because he was locked on to his first read plus he took a sack when he should have thrown the ball away. I'm going to try to watch some games of Moore (Oregon), Mensah (Miami), and Carr (Notre Dame) since we will obviously be taking a QB early in next year's draft and hopefully one of them looks a little more NFL ready.
Wow. Look at the fundamentals! Great footwork, both hands on the ball with the nose tucked up by his ear. Looks like Dan Marino with a set of wheels! And the ball jumps out of his hand.
We should have (5) 1st round draft picks by then, sign me up!
Is there any possibility AB drafts Jeremiah Smith with his first pick and draft LaNorris Sellers later in the first round?
Always a possibility. It depends on where that second 1st rounder is positioned and how many QBs actually declare. It also depends on how the rookie WR's on our roster play.
We did invest in the WR position. I am not sure we will do so again this year if they play well.
If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
Darian Mensah is the first FBS quarterback in the last 30 years to have more touchdown passes (14) than incompletions (12) through his first four games.
Darian Mensah is the 1st Miami player with 3 Pass TD & a Rush TD in a first half in the last 30 seasons.
I saw the play where he fumbled and the guy picked it up and ran like 80 yards for a TD.
Mateer has decent numbers but nothing special for sure. I thought he would be better. I don't know much about the team.
I saw the hit Dante Moore took. Disgusting. He could have been paralyzed. They threw the guy out of the game but he should be suspended. Moore went into a slide and that guy targeted his head. It was a bad screen. I really feared for Moore. He was on the field 20 minutes before they got him on a stretcher and carted off the field.
I watched Manning in the Texas vs TN game. He looks ok but he seems slow in processing to me.
Chambliss is small but damn he is a hellava playmaker. Smart, fast, elusive, savvy. Makes plays with arms and legs.
Darian Mensah is the first FBS quarterback in the last 30 years to have more touchdown passes (14) than incompletions (12) through his first four games.
Darian Mensah is the 1st Miami player with 3 Pass TD & a Rush TD in a first half in the last 30 seasons.
YDS 1,211
TD 14
INT 0
QBR 93.9
What else can a qb do?
His poise and control is special.
Now we just need him to go up against a team with an actual defense.
Stanford ranked 111 Florida A&M ranked 108 Wake Forest ranked 71 Central Michigan ranked 55
Clemson next up on the schedule ranked 68 Florida State after that ranked 128 THEN FINALLY... Pitt comes in at #16 nationally (Though they have played Miami OH/UCF/Syracuse/Bucknell, so might want to take that with a grain of salt)
The true test will be in a marquee matchup with Notre Dame, who is currently #1 ranked in defense. Irish have played (3) B1G teams and Rice.
Irish Vs Hurricanes will also feature CJ Carr, whom I think is a better prospect than Mensah overall.
We have to wait until November 7th to see it unfortunately!!
This goes here. A thumbnail of all the major qb’s thru 4 games. Chambliss is still studding out. Apart from one pretty golden moment I’m sure a few here will (always) remember, Manning looking like he may still need a year at this point. Moore hasn’t been great and now a concussion. Mensah wasn’t really on my radar, is now. Sellers looking very average.
'Peen, cogent observation. I like the pick, especially if the QB's look strong early. What you describe is doable and circle back for a favorite or best player available. Which current roster receiver could he replace and outperform? Does his size, his speed, his hands and blocking fit Monken's ideal? I think he can make a difference in the statistical play of the next QB who is NOT DW. I want him and I can settle for someone growing into QB position. How many more of his caliber do you expect in next few drafts. Two questions: One: Is he special? Two: Is he special enough for a move this major? I say yes. A player this solid strikes me as some comfort over one shot crapshoot with a QB who may bust. The metric for pay scale is attractive in comparison as well.
"Every responsibility implies opportunity, and every opportunity implies responsibility." Otis Allen Glazebrook, 1880
'Peen, cogent observation. I like the pick, especially if the QB's look strong early. What you describe is doable and circle back for a favorite or best player available. Which current roster receiver could he replace and outperform? Does his size, his speed, his hands and blocking fit Monken's ideal? I think he can make a difference in the statistical play of the next QB who is NOT DW. I want him and I can settle for someone growing into QB position. How many more of his caliber do you expect in next few drafts. Two questions: One: Is he special? Two: Is he special enough for a move this major? I say yes. A player this solid strikes me as some comfort over one shot crapshoot with a QB who may bust. The metric for pay scale is attractive in comparison as well.
I am not saying he doesn't look to be the next great WR.
A few thoughts on this situation. How high would we need to be in order to draft Smith? He probably won't go #1. Too many teams will be looking QB. I don't see out of the top 3 in the draft. At least right now we won't be picking that high. As good as the guy might be, I wouldn't trade the other 1st rounder for Smith and it would probably take that. I could see the Jets taking him 1st overall if they hold that pick because they have several more 1st rounders to get a QB as well.
Along these lines, what if we don't draft a QB in the 1st? What if we just use the other 1st rounders to keep building the team at other positions and look QB in the 2nd round or just go the FA QB route or trade route? Bone posted up a list of top names according to AI at this point. All aren't going to be drafted in round one. A guy like Gabriel might be Purdy like if we build around the QB position. I don't have any idea what QB's are slated to be free agents. Maybe we look there?
We do have other needs than at QB. A stud corner and another O lineman would look pretty good as drafted players. I know people love Judkins and I like him as well, but he isn't what I would call a stud. Maybe we look there?
In conclusion, what I am saying is if the wins don't stop at 3 or 4 and move up towards 8, maybe a QB isn't as slam dunk as we think. At least a 1st round QB.
If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
I do think we are drafting a quarterback no matter where the pick lands.
Unless Berry feels that whoever is left when we pick is not worth the pick.
Right now at 3-1 with the schedule we face going forward. It is game by game for me.
There are a number of quarterbacks that could be available like Nico Iamleava who could be very intriguing.
I like winning so I am just riding the unexpected wave.
I would remove Nico Iamleava from your list. Adter what he did to Jimmy Haslam's Tennessee Volunteers I do not think Jimmy would ever give Berry the go ahead to draft that kid.
All the draft guys have Moore, Manning as the top two.
It is still early but every time I watch Mensah. He looks very good. Very.
Does it include strength of schedule and NCAA defensive ratings?
Reminder of Mensah's current state of opponent: Stanford ranked 111 Florida A&M ranked 108 Wake Forest ranked 71 Central Michigan ranked 55 Clemson ranked 68 Florida State next ranked 128 THEN FINALLY... Pitt comes in at #16 nationally (Though they have played Miami OH/UCF/Syracuse/Bucknell, so might want to take that with a grain of salt) The true test will be in a marquee matchup with Notre Dame, who is currently #7 ranked in defense. Irish have played (3) B1G teams and Rice.
To compare to my pick of the litter, CJ Carr Wisconsin ranked #29 Rice ranked #105 Michigan State ranked #67 Purdue ranked #130 North Carolina ranked #43 with upcoming; BYU #17 MIAMI now #1
If anyone wants to look at what QB play looks like in NCAA that can (not guaranteed mind you) translate to the NFL, watch the Miami vs Notre Dame game November 7th! This is a marquee match up of arguably the two best QBs going against two of the best defenses in the NCAA.
BTW, I do think Manning has a nice career ahead of him in the NFL. He has fixable issues, but I believe he is going to end up being as good as his uncle Eli.
I trust the draft guys more than I trust AI. They have all the metrics and then some.
AI has all the metrics the draft guys (talking heads, is who I am assuming this refers to) do and more. It also knows better how to analyze those metrics. The best part of being an actual employee of a NFL Franchise is you have access to the players during the off season. A live person will be able to get a better understanding of the person through multiple conversations with the young man that can make a difference in those prospects that the metrics have too close to call.
That's one part of my point. And no, I wasn't referring to the talking heads. I was talking about NFL GM's.
You see they have the same access to all of the AI database that was shown above. So there's nothing proprietary about that. On top of that they have entire scouting departments and in person interviews that tell you more about a player than statistics do. If such statistics alone told the entire story I may agree. But it doesn't so I don't.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
That's one part of my point. And no, I wasn't referring to the talking heads. I was talking about NFL GM's.
You see they have the same access to all of the AI database that was shown above. So there's nothing proprietary about that. On top of that they have entire scouting departments and in person interviews that tell you more about a player than statistics do. If such statistics alone told the entire story I may agree. But it doesn't so I don't.
Well, I'm almost positive Bone was talking about the talking heads... What NFL GM is giving out his road map to who he thinks is the best QB in a draft that hasn't happened yet?
Even all of the talking heads have access to all of this information. So I'm not sure how you can conclude AI knows more. Then even you yourself pointed out the difference in the defenses that he had faced in a counterpoint to the very rankings bone posteded from AI.
So I'm not quite sure which side of this debate you're on?
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
Even all of the talking heads have access to all of this information. So I'm not sure how you can conclude AI knows more. Then even you yourself pointed out the difference in the defenses that he had faced in a counterpoint to the very rankings bone posteded from AI.
So I'm not quite sure which side of this debate you're on?
Well, first I was agreeing with Bone and didn't really think this was technically a debate at this point.. I was just curious if the defenses were included in the analysis. The analysis can run as deep as the analyzer goes down a rabbit hole. You can start out with a vague question, then add details to drill it down further and further. JUST going off of game stats vs historical value is one thing, but in the day of AI, adding in the defensive tendencies of the opponents, which is information AI can already take into consideration, will drill it down that much further.
You made a bold statement based on his post and I asked you for some clarification as well. To clarify further, are you asking for a debate on the reliability of AI vs "Draft Guys"? I'm just not sure where you are going with this. If that's what you are looking for, I'm going to bow out right now.. AI can't do anything without someone asking the questions.. "Draft guys" can't do anything without knowing the right questions to ask. All AI does is speed up the process for someone analyzing the players we are discussing. It isn't about which one is better, AI can't do anything without the human, but the human can do it so much better with AI.
I will argue that if you are going to put an old time scout that refuses to use AI in a room with a novice person that knows AI and the sport and neither get an opportunity to speak directly to the player, their close friends/relatives/coaches/teammates... Then the argument turns to watching game film and all the information that can be gathered. Someone that only turns on a computer and "analyzes" a player based on stats is going to get schooled by the old timer that has watched every play of a player the past two seasons, while making notes of each of those plays. However, if the novice understands the game, watches every play AND utilizes AI in sorting that information that he now has the knowledge to ask the right questions.. then I would go with the novice.
Could the old time evaluate every defense the QB has ever gone up against? Sure, but it would take him years compared to AI who can do it in minutes. They don't have years to get the packets on each player put together for draft season. In the past they had a snapshot of what each player is, now that picture is so much more complete, because the old timers that refuse technology are no longer employed.
Edit: Now, going to the talking heads, they typically play off of each other rather than actually putting in hours of analysis on each player.. that is a whole other discussion. They have deadlines and that is more important than getting all the relevant information in front of them. Many of them don't even watch game film. They just do a quick AI question on consensus of the others talking about the same subject. None of which might have used all the tools necessary to render their opinions.
Just for the hell of it I asked ChatGPT about the list - then specifically if there was any data to know which has the faster/fastest release and who processes faster thru progressions:
CJ Carr — possibly the best natural processor
This is the one I want to emphasize.
If you asked me:
"Which of these guys looks most comfortable going through a full-field progression?"
I'd have Carr and Sayin very close.
Carr doesn't necessarily look spectacular doing it. That's part of what I like.
He gets through the progression, recognizes the coverage, resets his feet and delivers the ball without excessive movement.
He's a very rhythmical quarterback.
The thing I'd like to see more of is Carr doing it against defenses that can consistently disguise coverage and pressure him. Notre Dame's protection and overall offensive structure make his job considerably easier.
But I think his mental processing may actually be one of his biggest NFL selling points.
Sayin vs Carr
If I had to split them:
Sayin
quicker release perhaps slightly quicker eyes better at manipulating the pocket excellent anticipation very efficient
Carr
perhaps slightly more natural progression QB excellent anticipation very calm very consistent footwork less reliant on predetermined throws
The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
I'm saying exactly what I've been saying. AI is one useful tool in a toolbox. It's not the be all, end all. I'm also saying everyone has access to AI so there is nothing proprietary about that. Another thing I can tell you is that the question you ask, the way you phrase the question and what AI source you ask will give you differing results.
Once again I was comparing it to NFL GM's who also have all of the AI information as well as the opportunity to interview these players one on one. Something AI can not duplicate and is extremely valuable in the process.
I would like to ask you, do you think that NFL quality scouting departments do not speak directly to the players close friends/relatives/coaches/teammates? That's a critical part of the scouting process. And somewhere along the line here I believe you either forgot about or have totally decided to ignore the fact that every team in the NFL and most professional sports has an analytics department. And that is the very purpose of AI. Breaking down all the numbers and angles on players. It's been in use for a very long time now. I believe coming to some conclusion that NFL teams aren't fully embracing and using AI as a tool is naive at best.
And then I also have to wonder. Does AI value all factors in judging a QB equally or give higher priorities to those special skills? I think most everyone is in agreement that the ability to go through your reads while reading a defense quickly is one of the most valuable and hard to find qualities in a QB. So does AI give those things much more gravity when grading QB's than other QB skills?
Just for giggles I asked Gemini this question. "Rank the 27 quarterback class based upon the most advanced metrics available." And my list ranked them very differently than the answer bone got.
Thee current analytical ranking of the class’s top prospects emphasizes translatable NFL traits, efficiency, and performance under pressure:
1. Dante Moore | Oregon (Model Rank: QB1)
• The Metrics: Led the FBS with 30 big-time throws. He is highly valued by NFL scouts for his elite physical upside and an exceptionally accurate quick game. • Scouting Outlook: Despite some high-variance tape, evaluators overwhelmingly favor his natural tools. In an ESPN poll of 25 NFL scouts and executives, Moore captured 14 first-place votes to be the top QB selected in 2027.
2. Julian Sayin | Ohio State (Model Rank: QB2)
• The Metrics: Boasts the #1 overall FBS PFF grade among eligible underclassmen and an elite 1.4% turnover-worthy play rate. His analytical profile is anchored by a class-leading 55.3 FRED score, proving his elite down-to-down efficiency. • Scouting Outlook: Sayin is regarded as the most pure throw-for-throw accurate passer in the class. Concerns exist regarding his average arm velocity and a frame that has invited pressure/sacks, but his microscopic mistake rate keeps him at the top of advanced models . 3. Arch Manning | Texas (Model Rank: QB3)
• The Metrics: Manning possesses an elite arm and mental processing profile, matching the ideal NFL build (6'4", 222 lbs). However, advanced metrics reflect recent late-September volatility—he currently ranks 29th in ESPN's QBR (67.6) due to deep-ball inconsistency. • Scouting Outlook: Despite metrics showing a slight plateau in continuous production, his traits are undeniable. He secured 7 first-place votes from NFL executives, locked in as a premier talent whose ceiling matches anyone in the class.
4. Darian Mensah | Miami (Model Rank: QB4)
• The Metrics: Mensah is the fastest-rising statistical marvel in the country, leading the FBS with an astonishing 88.7% completion percentage alongside a 39.4 FRED score. • Scouting Outlook: Analytical models are heavily heavily weighting Mensah’s absurd efficiency in Miami’s explosive offense. Scouts note he is rising "like a rocket" due to his elite decision-making and coachability.
5. Drew Mestemaker | Oklahoma State (Model Rank: QB5)
• The Metrics: Boasts a strong 40.4 FRED score after leading the nation in passing yards prior to his transfer from North Texas. • Scouting Outlook: Favored heavily by traditional and volume-based analytical models, Mestemaker was recently named the No. 1 overall quarterback prospect on ESPN analyst Jordan Reid's Big Board.
6. CJ Carr | Notre Dame (Model Rank: QB6)
• The Metrics: Carr operates at a blistering pace with a lightning-fast average time-to-throw of 2.54 seconds. He features a 6.5% big-time throw rate against a 3.2% turnover-worthy play rate. • Scouting Outlook: Models appreciate his bloodlines and high-floor processing, though a lower FRED score (10.6) and below-average NFL arm velocity push him to a Day 2 projection.
Last edited by PitDAWG; 10/05/2601:32 PM.
Intoducing for The Cleveland Browns, Quarterback Deshawn "The Predator" Watson. He will also be the one to choose your next head coach.
What teams are likely to be looking for a Qb in round 1 next year? Not all will take one but here are the teams I feel would like to (at this point in time):
Browns Steelers Dolphins Jets Vikings Cardinals
To me, these 6 are for sure Qb hunting There are several others that are maybe's
That's one part of my point. And no, I wasn't referring to the talking heads. I was talking about NFL GM's.
You see they have the same access to all of the AI database that was shown above. So there's nothing proprietary about that. On top of that they have entire scouting departments and in person interviews that tell you more about a player than statistics do. If such statistics alone told the entire story I may agree. But it doesn't so I don't.
On the other hand, people have personal bias, or lets say gut feelings.
I think that can be both good or bad. AI doesn't have any of that. That is why it takes some of both. I wouldn't want a computer picking all the players, but I wouldn't want a person picking all the players without AI. In other terms, I see AI as Mr. Spock, a living AI being, who dealt solely in logical terms, incapable of thinking in emotional terms. Very valuable traits, but he wasn't captain of the Enterprise for a reason.
If everybody had like minds, we would never learn.
I would suggest this may be longer with injuries; before the end of the year, the number of QB's injured and the severity of each injury will determine who is playable/out and for how long. Some clubs are having headaches with their declared starters, much less than the second, third, or other alternate starters. DW has proven to be a surprise. Small favor, that, but the alternative is not brilliant. That market for a quality starter in a picked over market for QB could be challenging, especially with playoffs' imperatives.
"Every responsibility implies opportunity, and every opportunity implies responsibility." Otis Allen Glazebrook, 1880